Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Energy Meters: 7 Devices from Optical Reader to Smart Plug

Measuring electricity for the whole house or at the outlet: optical reader on the digital meter, smart plug, DIN rail only by a professional. Seven devices compared.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Shelly Pro 3EMImage: Jackery (Pressebild)
Contents13 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A smart plug only measures the appliance plugged into it. If you buy one to see the consumption of your entire home, you will be disappointed. For that, an optical reader goes on the digital electricity meter. With a FRITZ!Box, the FRITZ!Smart Energy 250 is the obvious place to start; without a FRITZ!Box, the powerfox poweropti is a better fit, or, for tinkerers with Home Assistant, a Hichi reader.

What is in your meter cabinet helps decide

Before ordering, it is worth taking a trip to the meter cabinet, because half of the buying decision is made there. If the disc of a Ferraris meter is still turning, no optical reader will work. Tibber states this explicitly for its Pulse, and it applies to all devices of this kind. It has to be at least a modern metering device, meaning a digital meter with a display.

On the front of the meter is an optical data interface, usually with a metal ring for the magnet. Through it, the meter sends its data via infrared. Out of the box, however, many meters only provide the meter reading.

For real-time power readings, you need a PIN. It comes from the metering point operator, which in most cases in Germany is your local grid operator and not your electricity supplier. You enter it with a flashlight or with a button; afterward, the menu should show INF set to ON and PIN set to OFF.

Tibber, powerfox and AVM keep lists of tested meter models, and checking them before buying saves you returns. Also consider the wireless connection. Meter cabinets in the basement are often dead zones, where DECT or a dedicated bridge usually reaches further than plain Wi-Fi. And finally, the question of cloud or home network: some devices require an account with the manufacturer, others work locally. Whether app fees will come up later is something you are better off clarifying in advance.

Optical reader, smart meter, dynamic tariff

An optical reader does not turn a modern metering device into a smart meter. According to the German Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur), the modern metering device does not transmit meter readings; only an intelligent metering system with a smart meter gateway transmits data to the metering point operator. In Germany, all households are to have at least a modern metering device by 2032.

A dynamic electricity tariff, whose price follows the power exchange, legally requires an intelligent metering system (Section 41a of the German Energy Industry Act, EnWG, according to the Federal Network Agency). According to the German consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale, since January 1, 2025, every household can request installation, which must then take place within four months. Additional costs may apply for this. For normal households, the Verbraucherzentrale usually advises against dynamic tariffs, because they bear the risk of high exchange prices alone. They become more interesting with an electric car, heat pump or battery storage.

So a meter alone saves nothing. It only shows where the electricity goes.

Seven meters sorted by installation location

ModelDesignConnectivityBest for
FRITZ!Smart Energy 250Optical reader, battery or USBDECT to the FRITZ!BoxHouseholds with a FRITZ!Box
powerfox poweroptiOptical reader, power adapterWi-Fi, app, smart home interfaceHouseholds without a FRITZ!Box, PV owners
Hichi WiFi v2Optical reader with ESP32, TasmotaWi-Fi, MQTT, localHome Assistant, ioBroker
Shelly Plug S Gen3Smart plug, 12 A, 2,500 WWi-Fi, MatterMeasuring and switching individual devices
FRITZ!Smart Energy 200 / 210Smart plug, 210 splash-proofDECT to the FRITZ!BoxIndividual devices indoors and outdoors
Shelly Pro 3EMDIN rail, three-phase, current transformersLAN, Wi-Fi, BluetoothEntire household, installation by a qualified electrician
Shelly EM Gen3Single-phase, two channels, current transformersWi-Fi, BluetoothIndividual circuits, installation by a qualified electrician

FRITZ!Smart Energy 250

AVM introduced the sensor in 2024. It attaches magnetically to the digital meter, reads via infrared and transmits via DECT to the FRITZ!Box. According to retailer information, it requires FRITZ!OS 8 and runs on two AA batteries or via USB. If you already have the box, you do not need another account or a bridge. PV owners should check the current product description beforehand to see whether feed-in from a solar system is displayed.

powerfox poweropti

Compatible with 95 percent of meters, says the Berlin-based provider, pointing to lists in its help center. Variants with different diodes must match the respective meter model. According to the manufacturer, the poweropti connects with Homey, SmartThings and Home Assistant and can be used to control PV surplus. The data runs through the manufacturer’s cloud. Read the price and service schedule beforehand; it tells you more than any marketing copy.

Hichi WiFi v2

An ESP32 and preinstalled Tasmota sit inside this small optical reader. Via MQTT, the values go to Home Assistant or ioBroker, with no manufacturer cloud at all. That requires some manual work, because you enter the meter script yourself in the Tasmota interface. According to the listing, a USB-C power adapter with at least 500 mA is not included. If you just want an app, this is not for you.

Shelly Plug S Gen3

Refrigerator, dryer, gaming PC: this smart plug is intended for individual appliances like these. According to Shelly, it switches up to 12 A and 2,500 W with resistive loads and is Matter-certified. Fan heaters at full power push it to its limit. With it, you can find the standby consumption of your TV corner within a few days. Switchable models are covered in more detail in our article on smart plugs (in German).

FRITZ!Smart Energy 200 and 210

Since the end of 2024, the well-known FRITZ!DECT 200 and 210 have been called FRITZ!Smart Energy. For the model 200, AVM specifies a measuring accuracy of ±100 mW up to 5 W and ±2 percent above that, plus a switching capacity of up to 2,300 W. The 210 is built for outdoors. Analysis runs through the FRITZ!Box, in quarter hours, days, months and years. Older listings under the old name are technically the same device.

Shelly Pro 3EM

Three-phase, on the DIN rail in the distribution board. It measures via current transformers placed around the conductors. Shelly specifies 1 percent measuring accuracy, a LAN connection and memory for at least 45 days. The manufacturer’s safety instructions leave no doubt that connecting it to the mains belongs in the hands of a qualified electrician. Laypeople should not turn this into a weekend project, even if some instructions online make it look that way.

Shelly EM Gen3

Single-phase, two channels, a 50 A transformer in the box; according to the manufacturer, the small version measures up to 80 A. It fits in a flush-mounted box or next to the appliance, for example to record a wallbox and heat pump separately. The same applies to installation as with the Pro 3EM.

And the Tibber Pulse?

An optical reader plus a bridge that connects to the router via 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi. According to Tibber, the Pulse sends consumption values every two seconds. We did not find it as a new item on Amazon.de, which is why it is missing from the table. It is mainly of interest to customers on a Tibber tariff.

Which device belongs where

  • Total consumption, FRITZ!Box available: FRITZ!Smart Energy 250. Get the meter PIN first.
  • Total consumption, no FRITZ!Box: powerfox poweropti, if you want an app and accept the cloud.
  • Home Assistant or ioBroker: Hichi WiFi v2, local and without an account.
  • Individual devices: Shelly Plug S Gen3 or FRITZ!Smart Energy 200, and the 210 for outdoors.
  • Solar system, wallbox, heat pump: Shelly Pro 3EM or EM Gen3, installed by a qualified electrician.

If you are planning a plug-in solar system, the rules are in our article on the balcony power plant with storage (in German). How measured values end up in automations is explained in our article on the control hub for the connected home.

Once you know your consumption, you should also check the price per kilowatt-hour. Deadlines, special termination rights and the typical bonus traps are explained in our guide on switching electricity providers (in German).

How to check your annual bill and set your monthly installment correctly is explained in our guide on checking your electricity bill (in German).

What the new digital meter costs and when it is mandatory is explained in our guide to the smart meter (in German).

If a battery storage system is to regulate itself according to household consumption, it depends on meters in the meter cabinet or on the meter; see our guide to zero feed-in (in German).

How to derive the runtime on a portable station from measured values is shown in our guide on calculating power station runtime.

How measured consumption turns into a storage calculation is shown in our guide with a balcony storage worked example.

Measuring becomes practical with a sleep therapy device, as our guide to the power station for CPAP shows.

How much power a room really needs is worked out in our guide infrared heating: watts per square meter (in German).

Protection zones, RCD protection and mounting height are covered in our guide to the bathroom fan heater.

Frequently asked questions

Does an optical reader work with every electricity meter?

No. No optical reader works on a Ferraris meter with a rotating disc. It has to be at least a modern metering device, meaning a digital meter with a display and optical data interface. Tibber, powerfox and AVM keep lists of tested meter models, and checking them before buying saves you returns.

Where do I get the PIN for the electricity meter?

From the metering point operator, which in most cases in Germany is the local grid operator and not the electricity supplier. You enter it with a flashlight or with a button. Afterward, the menu should show INF set to ON and PIN set to OFF; the meter then delivers power readings in real time.

Does an optical reader turn my meter into a smart meter?

No. According to the German Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur), the modern metering device does not transmit meter readings; only an intelligent metering system with a smart meter gateway transmits data to the metering point operator. Under Section 41a of the German Energy Industry Act (EnWG), a dynamic electricity tariff requires such an intelligent metering system.

Which meter for individual devices?

A smart plug such as the Shelly Plug S Gen3, which according to Shelly switches up to 12 A and 2,500 W and is Matter-certified, or, with a FRITZ!Box, the FRITZ!Smart Energy 200. For outdoors, there is the splash-proof model 210. That way you can find the standby consumption of your TV corner within a few days.

Can I install a Shelly Pro 3EM myself?

No. The Pro 3EM sits on the DIN rail in the distribution board, works on three phases and measures via current transformers. Shelly's safety instructions leave no doubt that connecting it to the mains belongs in the hands of a qualified electrician. The same applies to the single-phase Shelly EM Gen3.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.