Contents7 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The two devices control the same roller shutter, but they belong in different houses. If there is a homee hub in your hallway, take the Shelly Wave Shutter: it communicates via Z-Wave, homee officially supports it including slats, and Apple Home gets it through homee’s bridge. Only buy the Eve Shutter Switch if Apple Home alone is in charge and a Thread router is running in the house. Then it is the more elegant solution, with its own push button on the wall.
The full picture, with five models and every route between Apple Home and homee, is in the guide to shutter switches for Apple Home and homee. Here, it is only about this one head-to-head.
What a module behind the push button does differently from a complete switch
The Shelly Wave Shutter is a flush-mounted module. According to Shelly, it measures 37 × 42 × 16 millimeters, weighs 29 grams and disappears behind the push button that is already on the wall. Two inputs take its rockers. So your switch range stays exactly as it is.
With the Eve Shutter Switch, the rocker is new. It replaces the old push button completely and, according to Eve, fits existing frames built to the 55 mm standard, but it comes with its own buttons; the old rockers cannot be reused. In an apartment fitted throughout with Gira or Busch-Jaeger, this one switch therefore stands out. Whether that bothers you is best decided before you buy.
The differences in one table
| Model | Design and wireless | Load according to manufacturer | Slats | Hub | Price class (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelly Wave Shutter | module behind the push button, Z-Wave with 800-series chip, S2 encryption | 10 A per channel | yes, dedicated slat mode | Z-Wave hub required, such as homee with Z-Wave cube | 30-euro class (retailer information) |
| Eve Shutter Switch (Matter) | complete switch for 55 mm frames, Matter over Thread | 750 VA, max. 5 A per channel | no information from Eve | Matter controller with Thread border router | 100-euro class (Eve’s recommended price) |
Both need a neutral wire. Eve states this explicitly; for the Shelly, the wiring diagram with N and L shows it. In older houses, this wire is sometimes missing in the switch box. A look behind the cover settles that before you order.
Why homee does not see the Eve switch
homee adds devices via radio cubes: Z-Wave, Zigbee, EnOcean. So far, Matter only appears at homee in the opposite direction, as a bridge that passes homee devices on to other systems. The manufacturer nowhere describes homee itself adding a Matter device. For the Eve Shutter Switch, that means it ends up in Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa, SmartThings, Home Assistant or Homey. It does not end up in homee.
That sounds like a minor detail, and in everyday life it is not. The group „all shutters down“, the rule based on the sun’s position, the Homeegramm at 9 p.m.: none of them reach the Eve switch. You then end up maintaining two hubs. Our review of the Curry Smarter Wi-Fi shutter switch showed exactly this kind of island, just from a different direction.
The Shelly Wave Shutter, on the other hand, is on homee’s official device list, with position and slat position. If you are buying new, plan on the generation 7 Z-Wave cube; according to the homee team, new Z-Wave devices are only supported with it. In Apple Home, the shutter appears via homee’s HomeKit bridge, which the manufacturer still lists as a beta.
What speaks for the Eve Shutter Switch
Without homee, the picture flips. The Eve switch joins Apple Home directly via Matter, with no bridge needed. You create schedules in the Eve app, and according to Eve, they run on the device itself. If the internet goes down, the shutter still moves at the usual time.
On top of that comes shading based on the sun’s position, although Eve only offers it for Apple Home with the Eve app. And the switch works as a Thread router, so it strengthens the wireless network for other Thread devices in the house. For renters, on the other hand, there is a drawback: according to Eve, connection and installation belong in the hands of a qualified electrician. The same applies to the Shelly.
A word on availability. In the Eve shop, the switch was temporarily out of stock in early November 2026; retailers continue to carry it.
What speaks for the Shelly Wave Shutter
Price, first of all. For the cost of one Eve switch, you get three Shelly modules. In a house with ten windows, that adds up to an amount that also covers the Z-Wave cube.
Technically, the module brings what a Z-Wave home needs. It measures power consumption, learns the end positions in an automatic calibration run and can tilt external venetian blinds in its dedicated slat mode. As a mains-powered Z-Wave device, it also relays signals; Shelly states a range of up to 40 meters inside buildings. For households that already work with FIBARO actuators, as in our review of the FIBARO Roller Shutter 3, it is the obvious next purchase.
There is no Shelly app for this module. It is operated via the hub or the old push button.
How we would decide
Take the Shelly Wave Shutter if homee or another Z-Wave hub runs your house, if your existing switches are to stay or if your external venetian blinds have slats. With many windows, the price also clearly speaks in its favor.
Take the Eve Shutter Switch if Apple Home is your only hub, a home hub with a Thread border router is already in place and you want a new switch on the wall anyway. For one or two windows in the living room, that is a coherent choice.
And if you live with Homematic IP or an entirely different system? Then neither of the two fits as well as an actuator from your own system. The guide to smart shutter switches offers an overview.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Eve Shutter Switch and the Shelly Wave Shutter?
The Shelly Wave Shutter is a Z-Wave module behind the existing push button, so your switch range stays. The Eve Shutter Switch replaces the push button completely, fits 55 mm frames and speaks Matter over Thread. Shelly states 10 A per channel and a slat mode, Eve 750 VA and a maximum of 5 A per channel.
Does the Eve Shutter Switch work with homee?
No. So far, homee only uses Matter as an outgoing bridge and does not add Matter devices. The Eve switch ends up in Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa, SmartThings, Home Assistant or Homey; homee groups and Homeegramme do not reach it.
How does the Shelly Wave Shutter get into Apple Home?
Via homee's HomeKit bridge, which the manufacturer still lists as a beta. The Shelly Wave Shutter is on the official homee device list with position and slat position. For new Z-Wave devices, plan on the generation 7 Z-Wave cube.
Do both shutter switches need a neutral wire?
Yes. Eve states this explicitly; for the Shelly, the wiring diagram with N and L shows it. In older houses, this wire is sometimes missing in the switch box, and a look behind the cover before ordering settles the question.
Do the schedules on the Eve Shutter Switch run without internet?
According to Eve, schedules created in the Eve app run on the device itself, so the shutter still moves at the usual time if the internet goes down. Eve only offers shading based on the sun's position for Apple Home with the Eve app.
Is there an app for the Shelly Wave Shutter?
No, there is no Shelly app for this Z-Wave module. It is operated via the hub or the old push button.
Sources
- Shelly: Wave Shutter, technical data
- Eve: Eve Shutter Switch
- Eve: Press release on the Eve Shutter Switch with Matter
- homee: Compatible devices
- homee: Release Notes Core 2.40 (Matter-Bridge)
- homee: Z-Wave Cube Gen7
- voelkner: Shelly Qubino Wave Shutter (retailer information)
Where to buy
- Shelly Wave ShutterCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Eve Shutter Switch (Matter)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
