Contents6 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Same manufacturer, same 400 liters, same snap-together system. And yet there is exactly one question between these two composters that decides the purchase: should anything keep happening in winter? If you add kitchen scraps all year round, choose the insulated Garantia Thermo-King 400. If mostly grass and garden bed trimmings go in during the summer, or the bin absolutely has to be black, the lighter Eco-King 400 is enough.
Both come from our guide to thermal composters with lid and removal hatch, which puts six models for that spot by the hedge side by side. Here we look only at the two that most people waver between.
What insulation does and does not do
The Thermo-King has walls made of Thermolen. That is what Graf, the manufacturer behind Garantia, calls a foamed plastic made from recycled polypropylene. It is meant to keep the heat generated during decomposition inside the bin. The Eco-King has simple walls made of recycled plastic, without insulation.
How much difference that makes is answered soberly by the German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) in its composting guide, the Kompostfibel. The higher temperature and decomposition continuing in winter are supposed to speed up composting. A clear influence of the bin design on composting time, however, has not been proven so far. So do not count on harvesting soil noticeably sooner from the Thermo-King. Insulation is no turbo.
The real advantage lies elsewhere. In January, a family kitchen still produces potato peels, coffee grounds and apple cores. In an uninsulated bin, that simply sits on top during frost and waits. In an insulated one, decomposition is more likely to carry on. If you only compost from April to October, with the Thermo-King you pay for a feature you hardly need.
It is that simple.
Thermo-King 400 and Eco-King 400 side by side
| Model | Footprint and height | Walls | Hatches | Color | Weight according to Garantia | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garantia Thermo-King 400 | 74 × 74 cm, 84 cm high | insulated (Thermolen) | 2 filling, 2 removal hatches | green | 13 kg | Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de |
| Garantia Eco-King 400 | 70 × 70 cm, 83 cm high | uninsulated, recycled plastic | 2 filling, 2 removal hatches | green or black | 8 kg | Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de |
The number of hatches comes from the overview in the Garantia garden catalog. For both, Graf lists the same accessory base grid measuring 74 × 74 centimeters, which has to be ordered separately. It is a must as soon as voles or rats are around in the garden; the German Environment Agency recommends this as well.
Four centimeters, five kilos and one color
On paper, the dimensions look almost identical. Along a narrow hedge, though, those four centimeters count. The Eco-King stands on 70 × 70 centimeters, the Thermo-King needs 74 × 74. On top of that comes the space in front of the hatch, because you dig out the finished soil with a shovel or fork, and you need room to kneel there.
At 8 instead of 13 kilograms, the Eco-King is easier to move. Handy if the location shifts after all once the first year is over. Both are assembled without tools. The side panels slot into each other.
That leaves the color. Garantia offers the Thermo-King in green, the Eco-King in green and black. If you want the bin to disappear in front of a dark thuja hedge, that automatically leads you to the Eco-King. The offer below links to the black version.
The lid and the location
On the Thermo-King, according to Garantia, the lid can be locked into a summer or winter position. The setting regulates the air supply and at the same time secures the lid against wind. The Eco-King also has a windproof lid lock, but Graf does not describe a separate summer and winter position for it. The location recommendations differ slightly. For the Thermo-King, the instructions call for a sunny to partially shaded spot, sheltered from wind but not completely still. Graf sees the Eco-King in partial shade, for example under trees or hedges. What both have in common: level ground with contact to the soil, never on concrete or asphalt, and at least 0.5 meters of distance from the neighboring property.
And the smell? Neither lid prevents it on its own. Compost only starts to smell when it lacks air. Coarse material such as chipped shrub cuttings keeps it loose, grass clippings go in only in thin, wilted layers. During prolonged rain, the lid stays closed. Done.
Which composter for which garden?
Choose the Thermo-King 400 if you compost kitchen scraps all year round, have about 75 centimeters of space and green is not a problem. It is the more solid choice for families with a garden and a kitchen.
Choose the Eco-King 400 if the composter should be black, space is tight or you mainly collect garden waste in summer. You will only notice the five kilos less and the missing insulation if you want to compost in winter. If you have even less space, the original guide lists the Eco-Master 300 for 60 × 60 centimeters, and the basics on bin types are in the general composter guide.
We tested a somewhat larger thermal composter made of recycled plastic ourselves: the Thermokomposter 450 Liter Made in Austria.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Thermo-King 400 and the Eco-King 400?
The insulation: the Thermo-King has insulated walls made of Thermolen, the Eco-King has simple walls made of recycled plastic. The Thermo-King has a footprint of 74 × 74 cm and weighs 13 kg, the Eco-King 70 × 70 cm and 8 kg. The Eco-King is also available in black, the Thermo-King only in green.
Does the insulated Thermo-King compost faster?
According to the composting guide (Kompostfibel) of the German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt), a clear influence of the bin design on composting time has not been proven. The advantage of insulation shows in winter: in an insulated bin, decomposition is more likely to continue during frost.
Which composter fits if you only compost in summer?
The Eco-King 400. If you mainly collect grass and garden bed trimmings from April to October, with the Thermo-King you pay for a feature you hardly need. If you add kitchen scraps all year round, choose the Thermo-King.
Do you need a base grid for the composter?
As soon as voles or rats are around in the garden, yes; the German Environment Agency recommends this as well. For both models, Graf lists the same base grid measuring 74 × 74 centimeters, which has to be ordered separately.
Does the lid help against odors from the composter?
Not on its own. Compost only starts to smell when it lacks air. Coarse material such as chipped shrub cuttings keeps it loose, grass clippings go in only in thin, wilted layers, and during prolonged rain the lid stays closed.
Sources
- Garantia: Thermo-King composter
- Garantia: ECO-King
- Garantia: Thermo-King assembly instructions (PDF)
- Garantia: garden catalog with composter overview (PDF)
- German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt): Kompostfibel (PDF)
Where to buy
- Garantia Thermo-King 400Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Garantia Eco-King 400Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






