Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The most expensive printer on the shelf is often the cheapest one. If you print regularly, an ink tank printer usually works out cheaper than a cartridge model, even though the purchase price is higher. For the typical household, a three-in-one device with automatic duplex printing is enough, such as the Epson EcoTank ET-2950. Lots of scanning or faxing? Then you need a document feeder, and you end up one class higher.
What is actually different about an ink tank?
The ink comes from bottles; there are no cartridges. The principle is the same at Epson (EcoTank), Canon (MegaTank), HP (Smart Tank) and Brother. The differences lie in features and speed, and above all in how many pages a bottle delivers.
You calculate the cost per page yourself: bottle price divided by the manufacturer’s stated page yield. The result is the ink cost per page; paper and electricity come on top.
Which features matter in everyday use?
- Duplex: Not every device flips the sheet on its own. Some require you to turn it over by hand; with the older Epson ET-2870, for example, duplex is only possible manually according to the data sheet.
- Scanning and copying: For single letters, a flatbed is enough. For tax paperwork or multi-page contracts, an automatic document feeder (ADF) makes things much easier.
- Ink type: According to the data sheet, the Epson models in the 102 series use pigment ink for black and dye-based inks for the colors. If you print a lot of text, ask specifically about this with other brands.
The paper tray is underrated. 100 sheets at the back or 250 sheets in a front cassette makes more of a difference in daily use than the data sheet suggests.
How honest is the page yield on the box?
These are manufacturer figures. Epson describes its measurement as an adaptation of the ISO/IEC 24711 standard; the test pages are printed according to ISO/IEC 24712 in standard mode on plain paper. They have far less coverage than a photo. If you print a lot of images, you will not reach those numbers.
Then there is the first fill. According to Epson, part of the included ink is used to prime the lines to the print head, which is why Epson sometimes gives different figures for the bottles in the box than for refill bottles. With the ET-2950, the product text and the data sheet on Epson’s own page also contradict each other. For this model, the table therefore shows the refill bottle figures. Only compare figures measured the same way. Otherwise you talk yourself into a device.
And what about an ink subscription?
HP Instant Ink bills by printed pages, not by cartridges. The printer reports its ink level and reorders on its own. Unused pages roll over to the following month, up to a maximum of three times the monthly allowance. There are two things you should know. The printer has to be online at all times. And after you cancel, the subscription cartridges stop working at the end of the billing period. HP lists the DeskJet, ENVY and OfficeJet series as compatible devices. Smart Tank models are not on the list.
At Epson, the subscription for cartridge printers in the Expression Home and WorkForce lines is called ReadyPrint Flex. ReadyPrint MAX even includes an EcoTank printer. There, according to Epson, the minimum term is 18 months; if you cancel early, you may have to pay compensation and return the device. With an ink tank, even a heavy printer rarely needs a subscription. The bottles last a long time anyway, and you stay free of commitments.
Five ink tank printers compared
| Model | Functions | Duplex / feeder | Page yield according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Epson EcoTank ET-2950 | Print, scan, copy | auto duplex, scanning via flatbed | Refill bottles: 7,500 pages black, 6,000 pages per color | Household, school |
| Epson EcoTank ET-4950 | Print, scan, copy, fax | auto duplex, 30-page ADF with duplex scanning | Included in box: 15,100 pages black, 5,500 pages color | Home office |
| Canon PIXMA G3570 | Print, scan, copy | not reliably confirmed | 6,000 pages black, 7,700 pages color | Light users who print in color |
| HP Smart Tank 7305 | Print, scan, copy | auto duplex, 35-sheet ADF | Included in box: 12,000 pages black, 8,000 pages color | Families with paperwork |
| Brother DCP-T780DW | Print, scan, copy | auto duplex, ADF | Included in box: 15,000 pages black, 5,000 pages color | Text-heavy printing |
Epson EcoTank ET-2950
According to Epson, automatic duplex printing and black pigment ink are included; scanning is done via the flatbed. Epson states 15 pages per minute in black and white and 8 in color according to ISO/IEC 24734. Paper feeds from the back, with room for 100 sheets. School worksheets, forms, the occasional color picture: for that kind of household, this is the sensible middle ground.
Epson EcoTank ET-4950
Fax, Ethernet, a 6.1 cm touchscreen and a 30-page document feeder that scans both sides. The cassette holds 250 sheets. Epson states 18 pages per minute in black and white. In the Epson shop, it costs considerably more than the ET-2950. If you only scan occasionally, you are paying for convenience you rarely need.
Canon PIXMA G3570
Compact, MegaTank, print, scan, copy. Canon states about 6,000 pages per black bottle and up to 7,700 color pages, more in economy mode. For speed, Canon gives 11 ISO pages per minute in black and white. Whether it prints double-sided automatically is not reliably clear from the manufacturer’s information. If you need that, check the data sheet beforehand.
HP Smart Tank 7305
The 7305 combines automatic duplex printing, a 35-sheet document feeder and a 250-sheet input tray. HP states a maximum of 15 pages per minute in black and white, and according to HP the included ink should last for up to 12,000 black-and-white and 8,000 color pages. One detail speaks in its favor: HP sells the print heads as replaceable accessories, so if one fails, you do not have to replace the whole device right away.
Brother DCP-T780DW
According to Brother, the current three-in-one model in the Tankbenefit line prints double-sided automatically and has a 150-sheet cassette; retailers list a 20-sheet document feeder. According to Brother, the box contains two black bottles good for a combined 15,000 pages. For color, it is only 5,000. That suits households where mostly text comes out of the printer.
Which printer is right for me?
For a household with mixed needs, we would go for the Epson EcoTank ET-2950. It offers duplex and pigment black at a price that, according to the Epson shop, is well below the ET-4950. If receipts and contracts come into play in a home office, the Epson ET-4950 and the HP Smart Tank 7305 are the options: the Epson scans both sides and faxes, while the HP combines a document feeder with a 250-sheet tray but has no fax. Almost only text? Then the Brother DCP-T780DW, because of the large amount of black ink in the box.
If you only print a few pages a month, the extra cost of a tank model hardly pays off. A simple laser printer works with toner instead of ink and is often the more relaxed choice for pure text pages. If you mainly print photos, a multifunction device points you in the wrong direction. Our overview of photo printers (in German) is a better fit then.
If you are considering a color laser for the office instead of ink, our review of the Kyocera ECOSYS M5526cdw covers print quality, scanning and toner costs from real-world use.
Frequently asked questions
Is an ink tank printer worth it?
For heavy printers, usually yes, because the ink comes from bottles and one fill lasts for many pages. You calculate the cost per page yourself: bottle price divided by the manufacturer's stated page yield. If you only print a few pages a month, the extra cost of a tank model hardly pays off, and a laser printer is often the more relaxed choice.
How realistic is the page yield of an ink bottle?
These are manufacturer figures based on ISO/IEC 24711, using test pages with far less coverage than a photo. If you print a lot of images, you will not reach those numbers. Part of the first fill also goes into priming the ink lines. Only compare figures measured the same way.
Do I need an automatic document feeder?
For single letters, a flatbed is enough. For tax paperwork or multi-page contracts, an automatic document feeder makes things much easier. The Epson ET-4950 has one for 30 pages with duplex scanning and fax; the HP Smart Tank 7305 has one for 35 sheets but no fax.
Is an ink subscription like HP Instant Ink worth it?
With an ink tank, even a heavy printer rarely needs a subscription. HP Instant Ink requires the printer to be online at all times, and after you cancel, the subscription cartridges stop working. With Epson ReadyPrint MAX, the minimum term is 18 months, and canceling early may mean paying compensation.
Which ink tank printer suits lots of text?
The Brother DCP-T780DW, because according to Brother the box includes two black bottles good for a combined 15,000 pages, versus only 5,000 for color. It prints double-sided automatically and has a 150-sheet cassette. The Epson ET-2950 also uses pigment ink for black, which benefits text.
Sources
- Epson: EcoTank ET-2950, data sheet
- Epson: EcoTank ET-4950, data sheet
- Epson: How page yield is determined (ISO/IEC 24711/24712)
- Epson: ReadyPrint
- Canon: PIXMA G3570, specifications
- HP: Smart Tank 7305, product details
- HP: Instant Ink
- Brother: DCP-T780DW
Where to buy
- Epson EcoTank ET-2950View at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Epson EcoTank ET-4950Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Canon PIXMA G3570View at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- HP Smart Tank 7305View at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Brother DCP-T780DWView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de

