Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
After the first day trip, it hurts, and not in the legs. Many people blame the saddle and buy a wider one with gel. Often the saddle is not the problem at all; the missing cycling shorts are. Our recommendation for men is the short ROAD TO SKY bib shorts with reflectors; for women, the TVI bib shorts with zoned padding, which the retailer rates for five to six hours.
Why the padding belongs in the shorts, not on the saddle
The ADFC (German Cyclists‘ Federation) recommends padded cycling shorts for longer distances for two reasons. They make long hours in the saddle more comfortable, and they have no seams that chafe against the skin. The second point is underrated. Jeans have a thick cross seam in the crotch, exactly where pressure and friction build up with every turn of the cranks.
A pad in the shorts moves with the body. A soft saddle, on the other hand, gives way, the pelvis sinks in, and the pressure shifts precisely onto the soft tissue you wanted to relieve. That is why road cyclists ride on surprisingly hard saddles and wear the padding on their bodies.
What makes a good pad
Thickness alone says little. Gonso, one of the best-known German makers of cycling shorts, specifies two values for its pads: height and foam density. The range is wide. A soft comfort pad there measures 18 millimeters at 60 kilograms per cubic meter, a firm long-distance pad 12 millimeters at 80, and the women’s version even 120. A pad with gel inserts gets by with 8 millimeters.
The logic behind it: soft, thick foam feels good for the first twenty minutes and then gives way. Firmer, denser foam supports you longer. If you sit in the saddle for three hours or more, the firmer pad is usually the better choice.
Then there is riding position. Vaude classifies its pads exactly along those lines. At 12 millimeters, the road bike pad is the thinnest and has the firmest foam, because in the stretched-out position the load sits further forward. The touring pad is 15 millimeters thick and softer, intended, according to Vaude, for a more upright posture. The mountain bike pad is also 15 millimeters thick and has four layers, with a lattice foam to absorb impacts off-road.
And there are differences between men’s and women’s pads. Gonso offers an Elastic Interface pad for men only, with a channel zone in the middle intended to relieve the perineal area. Women’s pads are shaped differently because the pelvis is built differently. So buy by gender, not by color.
Bibs or waistband?
Bib shorts fit better. No waistband digs into your stomach when you lean forward, and the pad stays exactly where it belongs. The drawback shows up at the rest stop, when you need the restroom and first have to get out of your jersey and straps. For road bikes and long rides, we would still always recommend bib shorts.
Waist shorts are more practical if you sit upright, get off the bike often or want to wear them under regular shorts.
When it comes to size: snug rather than loose. Cycling shorts that feel comfortably roomy when you try them on standing up will wrinkle in the saddle, and the pad shifts a few millimeters back and forth with every pedal stroke. That very movement rubs the skin raw. Sit down on a chair as a test and lean forward. The pad should then sit under your sit bones, not behind them.
Six pairs of shorts, two designs
ROCKBROS states neither pad height nor foam density in its product names. All details are based on the retailer’s product descriptions; prices appear automatically from the retailer data.
| Model | Design | Pad according to retailer | Best for | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ROAD TO SKY Herren Träger-Radhose kurz mit Reflektoren | Bib, short | padded | Men, road and gravel | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| TVI Damen Bib-Shorts Zonen-Polsterung | Bib, short | Zoned pad, 5–6 hours | Women, long rides | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| TVI Damen Fahrradhose Zonen-Polsterung | Waistband, short | Zoned pad, 5–6 hours | Women, everyday riding and touring | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROAD TO SKY Herren Radlerhose mit 4D Sitzpolster | Waistband, short | 4D pad | Men, upright posture | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROAD TO SKY Herren Trägerhose Lang Gepolstert | Bib, long | padded | Men, fall and winter | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Kurze Atmungsaktive Radhose für Herren | Waistband, short | described as shock-absorbing | Entry level, short rides | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
ROAD TO SKY Herren Träger-Radhose kurz mit Reflektoren
Classic summer bib shorts. The reflectors are a small plus for riding home at dusk, since the ADFC specifically points out that leg movement is easy to spot. About the pad itself, the retailer says nothing beyond “padded.”
TVI Damen Bib-Shorts Zonen-Polsterung
The only shorts in this selection with a stated ride duration. Five to six hours is a manufacturer figure of the kind pad makers often give, and it refers more to foam firmness than to a promise. Zoned padding means that different areas have different firmness.
TVI Damen Fahrradhose Zonen-Polsterung
The same padding promise, but with a waistband instead of straps. For women who get off the bike often or wear the shorts under regular shorts in everyday life.
ROAD TO SKY Herren Radlerhose mit 4D Sitzpolster
“4D” is a marketing term with no fixed meaning. It usually refers to a pad with several zones of different thickness. The size appears twice in the name: Asian size L corresponds to EU M. Order by the EU size.
ROAD TO SKY Herren Trägerhose Lang Gepolstert
For the cold season. The ADFC calls long thermal cycling tights the standard in cold weather. Whether these bibs have a warming inner lining the name does not say, only that they are long and padded.
ROCKBROS Kurze Atmungsaktive Radhose für Herren
The cheapest shorts here. For after-work rides and a first try to see whether cycling shorts help you at all, they are good enough. If you ride more after that, switch to bib shorts.
Care that makes the pad last
Follow the sewn-in care label first. For tight-fitting cycling shorts, Gonso states that 30 degrees in the machine is enough, with a mild liquid detergent and no fabric softener. They do not belong in the dryer; according to the manufacturer, that shortens their lifespan. Before washing, close any hook-and-loop fasteners on jerseys or gloves, otherwise the Velcro pulls threads out of the shorts fabric. And a sweat-soaked pad is not something you wear a second time.
How we would decide
Road bike or gravel bike, rides of two hours or more: bib shorts, ROAD TO SKY for men, TVI for women. Upright on a trekking bike: waist shorts, and in that case pay particular attention that the pad is not too thin. Fall and winter: the long bib tights. And before you buy a new saddle, try the shorts first. That is cheaper.
Frequently asked questions
Why cycling shorts instead of a soft saddle?
The ADFC (German Cyclists' Federation) recommends padded cycling shorts for longer distances because they make sitting more comfortable and have no chafing seams. A soft saddle gives way, the pelvis sinks in and the pressure shifts to the soft tissue. A pad in the shorts, on the other hand, moves with the body.
Is a thick chamois better?
Thickness alone says little. Gonso specifies height and foam density: a soft comfort pad measures 18 millimeters, a firm long-distance pad 12 millimeters with higher density. Soft foam gives way after a while, firm foam supports you longer. If you sit in the saddle for three hours or more, the firmer pad is usually the better choice.
Bib shorts or waist shorts?
Bib shorts fit better: no waistband digs in when you lean forward, and the pad stays in place. The drawback shows when you need the restroom. Waist shorts are more practical if you sit upright, get off the bike often or wear them under regular shorts.
Are there differences between women's and men's pads?
Yes, women's pads are shaped differently because the pelvis is built differently. Gonso, for example, offers a men-only pad with a channel zone intended to relieve the perineal area. So buy the shorts by gender, not by color.
How tight should cycling shorts fit?
Snug rather than loose. Shorts that feel comfortably roomy while standing will wrinkle in the saddle, the pad shifts back and forth and rubs the skin raw. Sit down on a chair and lean forward as a test: the pad should sit under your sit bones.
How do you wash cycling shorts properly?
The care label comes first. Gonso states that 30 degrees in the machine with a mild liquid detergent and no fabric softener is enough. The shorts do not belong in the dryer. Close any hook-and-loop fasteners on jerseys or gloves so they do not pull threads.
Sources
- Gonso: Seat pad overview
- Gonso: Care instructions
- Vaude: Which seat pad is right? (in German)
- ADFC: Accessories and clothing for everyday cycling (in German)
- ADFC: The right clothing for cold weather (in German)
- ADFC: Tips for cycling in winter (in German)
- Elastic Interface
Where to buy
- ROAD TO SKY Herren Träger-Radhose kurz mit ReflektorenView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- TVI Damen Bib-Shorts Zonen-PolsterungView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- TVI Damen Fahrradhose Zonen-PolsterungView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROAD TO SKY Herren Radlerhose mit 4D SitzpolsterView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROAD TO SKY Herren Trägerhose Lang GepolstertView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Kurze Atmungsaktive Radhose für HerrenView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.







