Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Backpack or a bag on the rear rack? For the daily commute, the bag usually wins because your back stays free and you don’t arrive sweaty. Still, many people ride with a backpack, and for good reasons: no rack on the road bike, constantly getting on and off, walking between the train and the office. For this kind of routine, we consider a convertible model the smartest choice, such as the 3-in-1 backpack from ROCKBROS, which according to the retailer also works as a rack bag and shoulder bag. On a mountain bike, things look different.
The real problem is sweat
A backpack sits on the part of the body that gives off the most heat while cycling. Ride briskly for twenty minutes, and your back is wet. That is unpleasant at the office and dangerous in winter, because on a descent or at a red light, the damp fabric cools down quickly.
Manufacturers tackle this with two designs. With a ventilated back, a tensioned mesh holds the pack body at a distance, and air flows in between. Vaude recommends such systems for sweaty rides. With a body-contact back, on the other hand, the backpack lies flat against you, often with padding and ventilation channels. It sits more securely, the center of gravity stays close to the body, and that is precisely why, according to Vaude, it was developed primarily for riding in demanding terrain. A mesh back sits correspondingly less securely there.
For the city, that means: the shorter and flatter the route, the less the system matters. The longer and sportier, the more ventilation counts.
Adjusted correctly, half as heavy
A backpack that slides up when you lean forward presses on your neck and gets in the way when you look over your shoulder. Vaude describes the fitting in four steps, and it is worth every minute. First, loosen all the straps. Then close the hip belt; it belongs on the upper edge of the pelvic bone. Next, get into riding position, and only now tighten the shoulder straps. Finally, close the load lifters and chest strap, also in riding position.
Pack heavy items close to your back and low down. A laptop belongs in the compartment right against your back, not in the front pocket. And think about what doesn’t need to go in the backpack at all. A water bottle and tools often fit on the frame, too.
How many liters?
The volume often already tells you the purpose. A look at the lineup of a major manufacturer shows the range. Vaude builds its lightweight bike backpacks for sporty rides with 8, 12 and 16 liters, trail models with 10 to 20 liters and a city backpack for cycling with 23 liters. If you carry a laptop, a spare shirt, a lunch box and a rain jacket every day, we estimate you will land somewhere between 18 and 25 liters. For an after-work ride with a spare tube, pump and windbreaker, half that is enough.
Bigger is not automatically better. A half-empty 30-liter backpack sloshes back and forth as you ride.
Rain and darkness
The ADFC, the German cyclists‘ association, considers a waterproof rack bag, or at least a model with a rain cover, almost indispensable for everyday use. The same applies to a commuter backpack. Several models below have „Wasserdicht“ (waterproof) in their name. Exactly how watertight they are, whether with welded seams or a roll-top closure, the name does not reveal. If you carry documents or a laptop, put them in an additional protective sleeve.
A backpack also covers the back of your jacket, including any reflective strips on it. Look for reflective elements on the backpack itself or use a reflective rain cover.
Five backpacks for cycling compared
All features according to the product names at ROCKBROS. Prices appear automatically from the retailer data.
| Model | Volume per retailer | Special feature | Best for | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 in 1 Wasserdicht Gepäckträgertasche Rucksack Umhängetasche 18L | 18 liters | also fits on the rack | Commuters with a trekking or city bike | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Wanderrucksack Wasserdicht Split 2 in 1 Rucksack für Fahrrad 24L | 24 liters | splits in two, waterproof | Day trips, shopping | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| Fahrrad Rucksack Wanderrucksack 17,5L Trekkingrucksack | 17.5 liters | cycling and hiking | Trips with stretches on foot | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| 17L Outdoor Rucksack mit 2L Hydration Bladder | 17 liters | 2-liter hydration bladder | Long rides | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Ultraleicht Trinkblase Rucksack Fahrradrucksack mit Trinksystem 2L | not specified | ultralight, hydration system | Mountain bike, road bike | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
3 in 1 Wasserdicht Gepäckträgertasche Rucksack Umhängetasche 18L
On the bike, it hangs on the rear rack as a bag, and your back stays dry. From the bike stand to your desk, you carry it as a backpack or over your shoulder. For commuters who need both, this is the most sensible compromise. As with any rack bag, check whether the hooks fit your rack. The ADFC explicitly recommends doing so.
ROCKBROS Wanderrucksack Wasserdicht Split 2 in 1 Rucksack für Fahrrad 24L
At 24 liters, the largest here, waterproof according to the retailer and separable into two parts. That suits the weekly grocery run by bike or day trips where a jacket and provisions have to come along. Fully loaded, you will clearly feel it on your back, so the hip belt pays off here.
Fahrrad Rucksack Wanderrucksack 17,5L Trekkingrucksack
A hybrid for trips where the bike eventually stays behind and you continue on foot. 17.5 liters is enough for a change of clothes and food. The name gives no details about the back system.
17L Outdoor Rucksack mit 2L Hydration Bladder
A similar size, but with a hydration bladder. The tube runs over your shoulder to the front, so you can drink while riding without taking your hand off the handlebar. How much room remains next to the full bladder, the name does not reveal.
ROCKBROS Ultraleicht Trinkblase Rucksack Fahrradrucksack mit Trinksystem 2L
The lightweight option for sporty rides on a mountain bike or road bike, with a hydration system. Such backpacks usually hold little more than water, a spare tube and a jacket. It is not made for commuting with a laptop. For a Sunday in the mountains, on the other hand, that very limitation is the advantage.
So who really needs a bag?
If you ride more than half an hour every day, summer and winter, and have a rear rack, you are better off with a rack bag. Your back will thank you. The ADFC describes the advantage in very practical terms: with a waterproof bag on the rack, you can carry a notebook, small purchases and anything else useful regardless of the weather, and in the evening it goes from the bike into the house in one move. The different designs, from the Back-Roller to the handlebar bag, are covered in our guide to the bike bag. For notebooks over 15 inches, it is also worth looking at laptop backpacks (in German) with a padded compartment.
On a mountain bike, by contrast, the backpack often remains the first choice. It keeps water, tools and jacket close to the body and barely sways with a properly adjusted hip belt.
Frequently asked questions
Backpack or rack bag for the commute?
For the daily ride, the bag usually wins because your back stays free and you don't arrive sweaty. If you ride more than half an hour every day and have a rear rack, you are better off with it. For road bikes without a rack or lots of walking, the backpack makes more sense.
What is the difference between a mesh back and a body-contact back?
With a ventilated back, a tensioned mesh holds the pack body away from you; Vaude recommends this for sweaty rides. A body-contact back lies flat, sits more securely and keeps the center of gravity close to the body; according to Vaude, it was developed primarily for riding in demanding terrain.
How many liters does a cycling backpack for commuting need?
If you carry a laptop, a spare shirt, a lunch box and a rain jacket every day, our editors estimate you will land between 18 and 25 liters. For an after-work ride with a spare tube, pump and windbreaker, half that is enough. Bigger is not automatically better; a half-empty backpack sloshes back and forth as you ride.
How do I adjust a cycling backpack correctly?
Vaude describes four steps: first loosen all the straps, then close the hip belt on the upper edge of the pelvic bone. Next, tighten the shoulder straps while in riding position, and finally close the load lifters and chest strap. Pack heavy items such as your laptop close to your back and low down.
How waterproof does a cycling backpack need to be?
The German cyclists' association ADFC considers a waterproof bag, or at least a model with a rain cover, almost indispensable for everyday use. The name alone does not reveal exactly how watertight the models with "waterproof" in their name are. Put documents or a laptop in an additional protective sleeve.
What should I watch out for in the dark with a backpack?
A backpack covers the back of your jacket, including any reflective strips on it. So look for reflective elements on the backpack itself or use a reflective rain cover so that you remain clearly visible from behind.
Sources
- Vaude: The right carrying system for a cycling backpack
- ADFC: Accessories and clothing for everyday cycling
Where to buy
- 3 in 1 Wasserdicht Gepäckträgertasche Rucksack Umhängetasche 18LView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Wanderrucksack Wasserdicht Split 2 in 1 Rucksack für Fahrrad 24LView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- Fahrrad Rucksack Wanderrucksack 17,5L TrekkingrucksackView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- 17L Outdoor Rucksack mit 2L Hydration BladderView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Ultraleicht Trinkblase Rucksack Fahrradrucksack mit Trinksystem 2LView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.








