Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A smoker has to fit your everyday life, not your weekend fantasy. If you regularly make pulled pork, ribs or brisket and do not want to add fuel every hour, the most convenient route is a pellet grill with an app, such as the Weber Smoque XL. Smaller budget, but you still want to sear directly over the flame? Then the Pit Boss Navigator 850G moves to the front. And if you love charcoal and have no power in the yard, stick with the classic water smoker.
How a pellet grill holds its temperature
At its core, a pellet grill is a convection oven with a wood fire. An auger feeds wood pellets from a hopper into a small fire pot, a fan stokes the embers, and a controller decides how much more goes in. You set a number. The grill holds it. That requires a power connection and more electronics, and electronics age.
How well that number is held depends on the controller. A PID controller measures continuously and makes fine adjustments; it is meant to bring the temperature back faster after the lid has been opened than a simple step control.
A strong smoke flavor develops at low temperatures. Weber has a dedicated mode for this called SmokeBoost, which holds around 80 degrees according to the manufacturer. At the top end, on the other hand, things stop early: most pellet grills top out at 260 degrees. That is easily enough for low and slow, but not really enough for a hard crust on a steak. Models with an open flame zone or a charcoal unit with a fan go considerably higher. If you are mainly after seared steaks, you do not need a pellet grill at all; a gas grill is faster and simpler for that, see our gas grill guide (in German).
Charcoal: with vents or with a fan
Charcoal smokers fall into two camps. The classic water smoker works without electricity; you control the temperature with the vents and a water pan that buffers the heat. That takes practice.
In the second camp, charcoal meets electronics. A fan regulates the airflow, the charcoal feeds down from a chute, and the result comes close to the convenience of a pellet grill, only with the stronger aroma of real embers. If you only smoke occasionally and already have a kettle grill in the yard, our kettle grill guide shows how to cook indirectly with it.
Hopper, probes, weight: the practical questions
The pellet hopper should hold at least one standard bag. Weber specifies 9 kilograms, Traeger around 11. On an overnight brisket, that decides whether you sleep or set an alarm.
Two meat probes are handy as soon as two cuts of meat are cooking at the same time. The app does not replace a look at the grill, but it saves you the walk into the yard. You should know beforehand whether your Wi-Fi reaches the grill. And then there is the weight: pellet grills easily weigh 50 kilograms or more, and wheels only help on firm ground. Ash has to be emptied from the fire pot regularly. A collection system that pulls out at the front saves time here.
Five smokers, five philosophies
| Model | Fuel | Temperature according to manufacturer | Control | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Smoque XL | Pellets, hopper for a 9 kg bag | up to 260 °C | PID, app via Wi-Fi/Bluetooth, 2 probes | Families who smoke often and in quantity |
| Traeger Woodridge | Pellets, hopper for around 11 kg | up to 260 °C | WiFIRE app, 1 wired probe | Anyone who wants the Traeger system |
| Pit Boss Navigator 850G | Pellets | 82 to 260 °C, flame zone up to 538 °C | Digital control | Smoking and direct searing on a smaller budget |
| Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800 | Charcoal in a chute | 107 to 371 °C | Fan, app via Wi-Fi/Bluetooth | Charcoal with convenience |
| Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cm | Charcoal, water pan | via vents, lid thermometer | Manual, no power | Purists and yards without an outlet |
Weber Smoque XL
Weber explicitly positions the Smoque line as a smoker, not an all-purpose grill. According to Weber, the XL version offers 5,922 square centimeters of cooking area, 3,838 of them on the main grate. That fits several racks of ribs side by side. Control is handled by a PID controller and the Weber Connect app, and two probes are included. The Smoque does not go beyond 260 degrees. For frequent searing, Weber offers the more expensive Searwood line, which is said to reach up to 315 degrees.
Traeger Woodridge
Traeger made the pellet grill famous. The Woodridge line is where the current lineup starts. According to Traeger, the base model has two grates with a combined area of around 5,500 square centimeters, a hopper for 24 pounds of pellets and WiFIRE for app control; a wired probe is included, and Bluetooth thermometers can be paired. Traeger gives a ten-year limited warranty on the grill. Traeger only lists the Super Smoke mode on the Pro version, and for frequent smokers that is a reason to go one step up.
Pit Boss Navigator 850G
Pit Boss solves the temperature problem differently. A slider opens a plate above the fire pot, and the meat then sits directly over the flame, at up to 538 degrees according to the manufacturer. That takes care of the biggest weakness of many pellet grills. Pit Boss specifies a cooking area of 5,671 square centimeters. There is no mention of app control for this version. To monitor from the couch, you will need a separate wireless thermometer.
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800
Here the charcoal stays. It sits in a vertical chute and feeds down on its own, while a fan holds the set temperature. Masterbuilt specifies 107 to 371 degrees, and a griddle is part of the concept. According to buyer reports, the firebox is a wear part. Stainless steel replacement inserts are available for the series, and it is worth budgeting for them from the start.
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cm
No plug. Among water smokers it is a classic, built from two grates each 57 centimeters in diameter, an enameled water pan, a lid thermometer and an access door for adding fuel. That is all it needs. Weber gives a ten-year warranty on the bowl, lid and center section. You manage the temperature yourself with the vents, which takes attention during the first few cooks; in return, there are no electronics to fail. If you have pizza rather than brisket in mind, our pizza oven guide (in German) is the better read.
Which smoker for whom?
Lots of smoking with little effort points to the Weber Smoque XL, with its large cooking area, two probes and app. Its drawback remains the 260-degree limit. With less money to spend and a taste for the occasional steak, you end up with the Pit Boss Navigator 850G and its open flame zone.
Loyalty to the best-known pellet system leads to the Traeger Woodridge, for frequent smokers preferably in the Pro version with Super Smoke. Charcoal, but with a controller, please: that is the Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800, with the firebox counted as a wear part. No power and plenty of patience? Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cm.
One more piece of advice on size. Buy the one you need every month, not the one for the single garden party a year, because a large cooking chamber has to be heated even when there is only a single cut of meat inside.
Which grate size suits your household and how much a kamado weighs is covered in our guide to the ceramic grill.
Frequently asked questions
How does a pellet grill work?
An auger feeds wood pellets from a hopper into a small fire pot, a fan stokes the embers, and a controller meters the supply. You set a temperature, and the grill holds it. That requires a power connection and more electronics, and electronics age.
Can you sear steaks on a pellet grill?
Usually only to a limited extent, because most pellet grills top out at 260 degrees. That is plenty for low and slow, but not really enough for a hard crust. The Pit Boss Navigator 850G has an open flame zone reaching up to 538 degrees according to the manufacturer. If you mostly grill steaks, a gas grill is faster and simpler.
What is the advantage of a PID controller?
A PID controller measures continuously and makes fine adjustments. It is meant to bring the temperature back faster after the lid has been opened than a simple step control. The Weber Smoque XL uses such a controller together with the Weber Connect app and two meat probes.
How big should the pellet hopper be?
It should hold at least one standard bag. Weber specifies 9 kilograms, Traeger around 11. On an overnight brisket, that decides whether you sleep or set an alarm. It also matters whether your Wi-Fi reaches the grill if you want to use the app.
Is there a charcoal smoker with automatic temperature control?
Yes, the Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800: the charcoal sits in a vertical chute and feeds down on its own, while a fan holds the temperature, 107 to 371 degrees according to the manufacturer. According to buyer reports, the firebox is a wear part; it is worth budgeting for stainless steel replacement inserts from the start.
Who is a smoker without electricity right for?
The Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cm is a water smoker with no plug, with two grates, a water pan, a lid thermometer and an access door for adding fuel. You control the temperature with the vents, which takes some attention at first. In return, there are no electronics to fail, and Weber gives a ten-year warranty on the bowl, lid and center section.
Sources
- Weber: Smoque XL wood pellet smoker
- Weber: Smoque wood pellet smoker
- Weber: Searwood wood pellet grill
- Weber: Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cm
- Traeger: Woodridge
- Pit Boss: 850G Navigator series
- Masterbuilt: Gravity Series 800
Where to buy
- Weber Smoque XLCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pit Boss Navigator 850GCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Traeger WoodridgeCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 57 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
