Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Three in the morning, eyes half open, and there on the ceiling in red digits: 03:12. That is exactly why people buy a projection alarm clock. Whether it is a pleasure in the bedroom or a nuisance, however, depends not on the size of the digits but on how far the projection can be turned down. That is why our first choice is the TFA Dostmann 60.5017.01: radio-controlled time, indoor climate on the display, a projection with two brightness levels that rotates through 270 degrees. If you only need the time and an alarm, the Technoline WT 538 will do.
Light in the bedroom: as little as possible
A projector brings light into the bedroom, and that is a genuine trade-off. In its sleep tips, the German health insurer DAK-Gesundheit advises creating a dark environment, banishing or taping over distracting lights and not looking at the clock at night. An alarm clock that throws the time onto the ceiling makes it easy to do the opposite. That is no argument against the device. It is an argument for models whose projection can be dimmed, shown at the push of a button or switched off completely.
Then there is a point that often only becomes apparent after unpacking. The projection only stays on permanently when the clock runs on its power adapter. Technoline says so for the WT 538 and WT 519, TFA for the 60.5018.01, Bresser for the MeteoTemp P. On battery power, the time only appears after you press a button, on the WT 538 for example for eight seconds. The batteries mainly serve as a backup during power outages. So plan for an outlet at the nightstand.
What really matters on the spec sheet
- Distance to the surface. Technoline specifies a projection distance of about 2 meters for the WT 538 and WT 519, and 1 to 4 meters for the WT 539. With a 2.80-meter ceiling in an older building and a 60-centimeter nightstand, it is already a good 2.1 meters to the ceiling. In that case, the wall next to the bed is the better surface, or you choose a model with a focus wheel.
- Rotation. Depending on which side of the bed you sleep on, the time would otherwise appear upside down. The WT 519 and WT 539 rotate through 180 degrees; TFA specifies 270 degrees for its two models.
- Brightness of the projection, not just the display. Two levels plus off are a real help; a simple on/off switch less so.
- Alarm tone. For the 60.5018.01, TFA describes a rising alarm tone; for the WT 538, Technoline describes a crescendo that changes volume four times. For light sleepers, that is more pleasant than beeping at full volume.
- Two alarm times, if people in the household get up at different times. The WT 519 and WT 539 have them, the WT 538 and the TFA models do not.
As for the radio-controlled clock itself: the DCF77 time signal is transmitted from Mainflingen near Frankfurt, Germany. The German national metrology institute PTB (Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt) gives its range as about 2,000 kilometers, and according to the TFA manual it broadcasts on 77.5 kHz. Reception problems therefore almost always have to do with the location. Technoline recommends keeping 2.5 meters away from TVs and monitors, TFA at least 2 meters from microwaves, baby monitors and refrigerators. Reinforced concrete also absorbs the signal. A spot near a window usually solves the problem.
Six projection alarm clocks with radio-controlled time
| Model | Projection | Temperature | Alarm | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TFA Dostmann 60.5017.01 | Time or indoor temperature, 2 brightness levels, 270° | indoor, plus humidity 10 to 99% | 1 alarm time, snooze | Bedrooms where you want little light |
| TFA Dostmann 60.5018.01 | Time, indoor, outdoor or alternating, 2 levels, 270° | indoor and outdoor, transmitter up to 100 m | 1 alarm time, rising tone, 10 min snooze | anyone who wants to see the outdoor temperature in the morning |
| Technoline WT 538 | time only, rotatable, about 2 m | indoor | 1 alarm time, crescendo | simple bedside alarm clock |
| Technoline WT 519 | Time and temperature, 180°, about 2 m | indoor | 2 alarm times, 8 min snooze | Couples with different wake-up times |
| Technoline WT 539 | Time and temperature, ±180°, 1 to 4 m | indoor and outdoor, sensor up to 30 m | 2 alarm times, frost pre-alarm | Commuters in winter |
| Bresser MeteoTemp P | Time and forecast symbol | indoor and outdoor, sensor up to 60 m with display | 1 alarm time, 8 min snooze | Weather station with alarm function |
TFA Dostmann 60.5017.01
For the bedroom, we consider this model the most well-rounded. TFA gives the projection two brightness levels and an arm that rotates through 270 degrees; the display has four backlight levels and an adjustable dimming function. The display shows temperature and humidity, while the projection shows the time, the indoor temperature or both alternately. According to the manufacturer, radio reception can be switched off. A power adapter is included; the three AAA batteries for backup are not.
TFA Dostmann 60.5018.01
The same housing at 149 × 38 × 104 millimeters, but with an outdoor transmitter that TFA rates at up to 100 meters of range. It measures from minus 40 to plus 60 degrees. If you like, the ceiling shows the time, indoor and outdoor temperature one after another. The manual describes automatic dimming, preset from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., and a rising alarm tone that stops after two minutes. Snooze pauses it for ten minutes. Only one alarm time.
Technoline WT 538
The simple one. It projects only the time, rotatable at the push of a button, at a distance of about two meters. According to the manual, the clock searches for the time signal at 1, 2 and 3 a.m. and briefly switches off the projection during reception. On the power adapter, the display glows bright, dim or not at all. The projection, on the other hand, can only be switched on and off according to the manual, not dimmed. In return, you get the crescendo alarm and an adjustable snooze time.
Technoline WT 519
More compact, almost cube-shaped at 129 × 92 × 34 millimeters, and with two alarm times. It throws the time and temperature onto the ceiling, and the projection rotates through 180 degrees. According to the manual, the indoor measuring range runs from minus 9.9 to 50 degrees. Two AA cells instead of AAA serve as backup.
Technoline WT 539
The alarm clock for people who scrape ice off their car in winter. A TX108 wireless sensor supplies the outdoor temperature; Technoline specifies 30 meters of range in open terrain. The pre-alarm is interesting: if the outdoor temperature drops below minus 3 degrees, the alarm rings 30 minutes earlier. According to the manual, the projector works at 1 to 4 meters and can be focused. The display color can be chosen from 256 shades. According to the manual, however, the projection is always on when the clock runs on the power adapter. If you like it pitch dark at night, you should know that.
Bresser MeteoTemp P
More weather station than alarm clock. Bresser projects the time and a weather forecast symbol; the display shows indoor and outdoor values for temperature and humidity, plus a frost warning and min/max memory. The wireless sensor has its own display and, according to the manufacturer, reaches up to 60 meters; two more sensors can be paired. The alarm goes off once a day, with an eight-minute snooze. According to Bresser, only the time and the forecast symbol go onto the ceiling; the readings stay on the display.
How we would decide
- You want as little light as possible at night: TFA Dostmann 60.5017.01, with the projection on the low setting.
- The outdoor temperature matters in the morning: TFA Dostmann 60.5018.01, or the Technoline WT 539 if you want it to ring earlier when there is frost.
- Two alarm times for two people: Technoline WT 519.
- Just the time, nothing else: Technoline WT 538.
- You are actually looking for a weather station: Bresser MeteoTemp P, or a device from our weather station guide (in German).
And if you would rather be woken gently than be precisely informed: a wake-up light works with slowly brightening light instead of digits on the ceiling. Our wake-up light guide (in German) explains the differences.
Frequently asked questions
Does the projection stay on permanently when running on batteries?
Usually not. Technoline, TFA and Bresser only describe continuous projection when the clock runs on the power adapter. On batteries, the time only appears after you press a button, on the WT 538 for about eight seconds. The batteries mainly serve as a backup during power outages, so plan for an outlet at the nightstand.
How far away can the ceiling be from a projection alarm clock?
Technoline specifies about 2 meters for the WT 538 and WT 519, and 1 to 4 meters for the WT 539. Under a high ceiling in an older building, the distance quickly becomes greater. In that case, the wall next to the bed works better, or a model with a focus wheel such as the WT 539.
Which projection alarm clock has two alarm times?
The Technoline WT 519 and WT 539 offer two alarm times, which helps when people in the household get up at different times. The WT 538 and the two TFA models have only one. The WT 539 also rings 30 minutes earlier if the outdoor temperature drops below minus 3 degrees.
Why is my radio-controlled clock not receiving a signal?
The DCF77 time signal is transmitted from Mainflingen, Germany, and according to the German national metrology institute PTB (Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt) it reaches about 2,000 kilometers. Problems are therefore almost always due to the location: Technoline recommends keeping 2.5 meters away from TVs and monitors, TFA at least 2 meters from microwaves, baby monitors and refrigerators. A spot near a window usually helps.
Does the light from a projection alarm clock disturb sleep?
It is a trade-off. The German health insurer DAK-Gesundheit advises a dark environment and not looking at the clock at night. That is why models whose projection can be dimmed or switched off make sense. According to the manual, the WT 539's projection is always on when running on the power adapter, and on the WT 538 it can only be switched on and off.
Which projection alarm clock shows the outdoor temperature?
The TFA Dostmann 60.5018.01 has an outdoor transmitter with a range of up to 100 meters and projects the time, indoor and outdoor temperature one after another. The Technoline WT 539 uses a wireless sensor with 30 meters of range. The Bresser MeteoTemp P is more of a weather station and only projects the time and a forecast symbol.
Sources
- TFA Dostmann: Radio-controlled projection alarm clock with indoor climate 60.5017
- TFA Dostmann: Radio-controlled projection alarm clock with indoor and outdoor temperature 60.5018 (with user manual)
- Technoline: WT 538 projection alarm clock and user manual
- Technoline: WT 519 and user manual
- Technoline: WT 539 and user manual
- Bresser: MeteoTemp P radio-controlled projection weather station
- Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB): Range of DCF77
- DAK-Gesundheit: Tips and rules for restful sleep
Where to buy
- TFA Dostmann 60.5017.01Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- TFA Dostmann 60.5018.01Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Technoline WT 538Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Technoline WT 519Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Technoline WT 539Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bresser MeteoTemp PCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
