Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A Saturday in Advent, three batches of dough in the fridge, and the first tray comes out of the oven half burnt. The recipe is rarely to blame. Usually the dough is three millimeters thick at one corner and seven at the other, and the thin stars turn black while the thick ones are still soft. If you only buy one new item, start with a large rolling mat with a grid, such as the Kaiser Inspiration fondant rolling mat. Cookie cutters, stamps and a cookie press come later.
First the surface, then the shapes
Cookie-baking gear is cheap. That is exactly why so much of it piles up, and most of it goes unused. You are better off with a small, solid basic kit that matches the kinds of cookies that really end up on your table every year.
When it comes to the material of cookie cutters: stainless steel does not rust and is usually dishwasher-safe. Tinplate often cuts more sharply but has to be dried thoroughly. Plastic is pleasant for children’s hands, but it tends to squash firm dough rather than cut it. Size matters too. Shapes between five and seven centimeters bake evenly; very fine points and antlers break off easily with crumbly shortcrust dough.
With a rolling pin, bearings are worth it. A plain or ball bearing lets the roller turn while the handles stay still, which is easier on the wrists when you roll large amounts. Wood and tinplate do not belong in the dishwasher; if that bothers you, go for silicone and stainless steel. And one more thing about storage: keep crumbly cookies and soft gingerbread (Lebkuchen) separate. Otherwise the one draws moisture from the other.
If you knead a lot of dough at once, a machine helps. What works for heavy shortcrust dough is shown in our stand mixer guide (in German) and in the overview of hand mixers (in German). Exact recipe quantities are easy with a good kitchen scale (in German), and pans for stollen and cakes are covered in the baking pan guide (in German).
Seven helpers for cookie season
| Model | Task | Key data according to manufacturer/retailer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kaiser Inspiration fondant rolling mat | Rolling out | Silicone, 60 x 40 cm, grid and templates, double-sided, non-slip | anyone who cuts out a lot of cookies |
| Westmark rolling pin »Woody« | Rolling out | Beech wood, 46 cm, plain bearing, 5-year warranty | large amounts of dough |
| Städter Christmas cookie cutter set, 6 pcs. | Cutting out | Stainless steel, six shapes, about 5.5 to 7 cm | classic cut-out cookies |
| Birkmann stamp set Angel & Deer | Embossing | Wooden handle, two silicone discs, 5 cm diameter | butter cookies with a pattern |
| Marcato Biscuits | Spritz cookies | 20 shapes, 2 sizes, metal housing | anyone who bakes spritz cookies every year |
| Westmark cookie press and piping gun, 250 ml | Spritz cookies, decorating | 8 stainless steel shaping discs, 8 nozzles, dishwasher-safe | occasional spritz cookie bakers |
| Birkmann XXL cookie tin Merry Christmas | Storage | Tinplate, 40 x 20 x 9 cm, compartment insert | several kinds at once |
Kaiser Inspiration fondant rolling mat
At 60 by 40 centimeters, a whole sheet of dough fits on the silicone mat. A grid and templates for round, rectangular and square shapes are printed on it; both sides can be used, and according to Kaiser it is also non-slip. Dough sticks less to silicone, so you need less flour. The grid shows immediately whether the sheet is even. One limitation: according to Kaiser, the mat must not go in the dishwasher, and Kaiser does not say whether it can go in the oven. It is a work surface. It does not replace baking paper.
Westmark rolling pin »Woody«
Beech wood, 46 centimeters, with a plain bearing inside. Warranty: five years. Westmark recommends washing by hand. You can manage two trays of vanilla crescents (Vanillekipferl) without this rolling pin. But if you work through four or five batches of dough on an Advent weekend, your wrists will feel the difference compared with a plain wooden rolling pin.
Städter Christmas cookie cutter set, 6 pieces
Angel, moose, moose head, fawn, snowman, fir tree. That covers the usual shapes, in sizes of roughly 5.5 to 7 centimeters according to the retailer. The cutters are made of stainless steel and are sold as dishwasher-safe. Six are enough for most families. Want more variety? Then add individual shapes selectively instead of buying a 30-piece set full of shapes that never get used.
Birkmann stamp set Angel & Deer
The wooden handle comes with two interchangeable discs made of food-safe silicone, each five centimeters across. Birkmann advises well-chilled dough and dipping the disc in flour every now and then so the pattern stays crisp. The handle must not be soaked; according to the manufacturer, the discs can go in the dishwasher.
Buyers of other Birkmann stamps report that hardly anything of the pattern remains after baking if the dough is not right. Birkmann itself recommends doughs that hold their shape during baking. Butter cookies are suitable; doughs that rise a lot are less so.
Marcato Biscuits
Many people know the Italian manufacturer from its pasta machines. According to Marcato, its cookie press forms 20 different shapes in two sizes, selected via a rotary knob, and it can be taken apart for cleaning. The Classic version is silver. The variant in seven colors is called Design and, according to the manufacturer, costs considerably more. Buyers praise the shapes but criticize the small capacity and the effort needed with very firm spritz dough. For occasional spritz cookies, you are paying too much here. If you bake them by the kilo every year, you get a sturdy device.
Westmark cookie press and piping gun, 250 ml
The Westmark press holds 250 milliliters and comes with eight stainless steel shaping discs and eight nozzles; the dough is dispensed via a lever on the handle. Westmark describes it as dishwasher-safe and BPA-free, and the warranty runs for five years. Thanks to the nozzles, you can also use it to decorate cakes.
Buyer reviews are mixed. Some praise the easy cleaning, others complain that the dough spreads out inside the device. A lot depends on the consistency.
Birkmann XXL cookie tin Merry Christmas
Tinplate, 40 by 20 by 9 centimeters, with a compartment insert: this keeps several kinds of cookies apart in one tin, and a stollen fits inside too. For its cookie tins, Birkmann points out that they are not dishwasher-safe and are intended for dry baked goods, not for moist or acidic foods. Gingerbread with a slice of apple therefore needs a tin of its own.
What we would buy in your place
Almost every household does best with the Kaiser rolling mat, because dough of even thickness does more than any new shape. If you roll out large amounts, add the Westmark »Woody« with its plain bearing.
- Classic cut-out cookies: the Städter set with six stainless steel cutters, adding individual shapes later.
- Butter cookies with a pattern: the Birkmann stamp set, only with chilled dough.
- Spritz cookies once or twice a year: the Westmark press. Frequent bakers go for the Marcato Biscuits.
- Storing and gifting: the Birkmann XXL tin with compartments for dry kinds of cookies.
Frequently asked questions
Which material makes sense for cookie cutters?
Stainless steel does not rust and is usually dishwasher-safe. Tinplate often cuts more sharply but has to be dried thoroughly. Plastic is pleasant for children's hands, but it tends to squash firm dough rather than cut it. Shapes between five and seven centimeters bake evenly; fine points break off easily with crumbly shortcrust dough.
When does a rolling pin with bearings make sense?
For large amounts of dough. A plain or ball bearing lets the roller turn while the handles stay still, which is easier on the wrists. The Westmark Woody rolling pin made of beech wood measures 46 centimeters and has a plain bearing. Wood does not belong in the dishwasher; Westmark recommends washing by hand.
Which cookie press is enough for occasional spritz cookies?
If you bake spritz cookies once or twice a year, the Westmark cookie press with 250 milliliters, eight shaping discs and eight piping nozzles will do. The Marcato Biscuits with 20 shapes in two sizes is aimed at frequent bakers; buyers criticize its small capacity and the effort needed with very firm spritz dough.
Why does the pattern from a cookie stamp not hold?
Usually it is down to the dough. Birkmann advises well-chilled dough and dipping the stamp disc in flour every now and then. Suitable doughs are those that hold their shape during baking, such as butter cookies. Doughs that rise a lot are less suitable for stamps.
How do you store Christmas cookies properly?
Keep crumbly cookies and soft gingerbread (Lebkuchen) separate, otherwise the one draws moisture from the other. The Birkmann XXL cookie tin with a compartment insert keeps several kinds apart. Birkmann points out that its cookie tins are intended for dry baked goods and are not dishwasher-safe.
Do you need a large cookie cutter set?
Six shapes are enough for most families, such as the Städter stainless steel set with angel, moose, snowman and fir tree. For more variety, it is better to add individual shapes selectively instead of buying a 30-piece set full of shapes that never get used.
Sources
- Kaiser: Inspiration fondant rolling mat 60 x 40 cm
- Westmark: rolling pin »Woody«, beech wood
- Westmark: cookie press and piping gun, 250 ml
- Birkmann: stamp set Angel & Deer
- Birkmann: XXL Christmas cookie tin (care instructions)
- Marcato: Biscuits Classic
- Marcato: Biscuits Design
Where to buy
- Kaiser Inspiration Fondant-AusrollmatteCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Westmark Teigrolle »Woody«Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Städter Ausstecher-Set Weihnachten 6-teiligCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Birkmann Stempel-Set Engel & HirschCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Marcato Biscuits GebäckpresseCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Westmark Gebäckpresse und Garnierspritze 250 mlCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Birkmann XXL-Gebäckdose Merry ChristmasCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
