Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Anyone fitting clipless pedals for the first time almost always falls over in the same spot. At the traffic light, at a standstill, because the foot does not come out in time. That is rarely the pedal’s fault and almost always the setup’s. For beginners and everyday riding, we recommend a dual-sided pedal with a clip-in side and a flat side, such as the ROCKBROS aluminum 2-in-1 pedals with SPD mechanism. If you do not want to clip in at all, the magnetic pedals from MAGPED offer a middle ground.
Two holes or three?
Before you think about weight or material, look under your shoe. That is where it is decided which system fits.
Shoes with two threaded holes take small metal plates, the cleats of the SPD system. It comes from mountain biking and is now also common on gravel, touring and recumbent bikes. You can usually clip in on both sides of the pedal, and dirt on the sole hardly affects the mechanism. Because the cleat sits recessed in the sole, you can walk almost normally. In the café, on the train platform, in the office hallway.
Three holes mean road bike. Here a large plastic cleat sits under a stiff sole; the best-known example is Look Keo, alongside Shimano SPD-SL. The pedal can only be clipped into from one side, and on foot you waddle on the cleat as if on a heel. In return, the foot rests on a wider surface. For the Keo Blade, for example, Look specifies a contact area of 705 square millimeters.
You cannot mix them. An SPD cleat does not fit a road shoe with three holes, and vice versa. So buy shoe and pedal as a pair, not one after the other and hoping for the best.
How firmly should the pedal hold?
You unclip by turning your heel outward. How much force that takes can be set on good pedals with a screw on the spring. Look gives unusually specific values for this: the softest spring at 8 Nm corresponds to about 4 kilograms of release force and is intended for beginners. The hardest at 20 Nm is around 10 kilograms, which is sprinter territory. Measurements were taken with shoe size 42 to 43 (EU). Larger feet have more leverage, while a cleat mounted further back makes unclipping harder.
The manufacturer’s advice is simple and right. When in doubt, the weaker setting. You can always tighten it later. Practice the first few times while stationary, leaning against a wall, then in an empty parking lot.
Then there is float: how far your heel can rotate while clipped in before the pedal releases. A few degrees of play are easier on the knees. For the beginner cleat X-Track Easy for mountain bikes, Look specifies 6 degrees of float and a 13-degree release angle, and it allows unclipping in several directions.
Does clipping in actually give you more power?
Less than many people think. The often-heard claim that you can also pull up with clipless pedals hardly holds up in studies. Under normal load, nobody pulls the pedal up, and on average you do not ride more efficiently than on flat pedals either. Only in a sprint can you briefly put more power into the crank.
The real gain lies elsewhere. Your foot always sits in the same spot, does not slip off in the wet and does not slam pins into your shin. On long tours that is pleasant, on rough forest trails reassuring. If, on the other hand, you get off often, in the city or with a child in the trailer, flat pedals often mean less stress. Dual-sided pedals exist for exactly this case.
Six pedals, three systems
Details on the ROCKBROS pedals are based on the retailer’s product name, details on MAGPED on the manufacturer. Prices appear automatically from the retailer data.
| Model | System | Special feature | Best for | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ROCKBROS Fahrradpedale Alu 2 in 1 SPD (aluminum 2-in-1 SPD pedals) | SPD, two holes | Clip-in and platform side | Everyday riding, beginners | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| SPD-Klickpedale und Plattformpedale 2-in-1 inkl. Cleats (SPD clipless and platform pedals, cleats included) | SPD, two holes | Cleats included | Tight budget | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS SPD Fahrradpedale mit Einstellbarer Spannung (SPD pedals with adjustable tension) | SPD, two holes | Adjustable spring tension | Gravel, touring, MTB | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| SPD Fahrradpedale 146g LOOK KEO Kompatibel (LOOK KEO compatible pedals) | Three holes, Keo cleats | 146 g according to the retailer | Road bike, beginners | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| Kohlefaser-SPD-Klickpedale für Rennräder (carbon fiber pedals for road bikes) | Road bike | Carbon body | Road bike, weight-conscious riders | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| MAGPED Road 2 Magnetic Safety Bike Pedals | Magnetic, three holes | Releases in any direction | Road bike without fear of clipping in | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
ROCKBROS Fahrradpedale Alu 2 in 1 SPD
One side with an SPD mechanism, the other flat. In the morning to the bakery in commuter shoes, at the weekend out on a ride in cycling shoes. For beginners, these pedals take the pressure off, because in heavy traffic you can simply ride on the flat side. The retailer markets them for mountain bikes, road bikes and city bikes. The name gives no information on spring tension.
SPD-Klickpedale und Plattformpedale 2-in-1 inkl. Cleats
The same principle in a cheaper version, but with cleats in the package. That saves a separate purchase if your shoes come without cleats. The axle is 9/16 inch, the usual thread for adult bikes.
ROCKBROS SPD Fahrradpedale mit Einstellbarer Spannung
A pure clipless pedal for two holes with an adjustable spring. For gravel and touring, the obvious choice once unclipping comes naturally. Set the spring as soft as possible at first.
SPD Fahrradpedale 146g LOOK KEO Kompatibel
The name is confusing. It says SPD, but according to the retailer the pedals are compatible with Look Keo cleats, meaning road shoes with three holes. Check which cleats are in the box before buying. At 146 grams per pedal, a lightweight way into the road bike system.
Kohlefaser-SPD-Klickpedale für Rennräder
A carbon body for the road bike. The product name does not clearly reveal which cleat system fits. Ask the retailer before buying shoes to go with them. For beginners, the extra cost over aluminum is hardly worth it; you will not notice a few grams on the pedal on the road.
MAGPED Road 2 Magnetic Safety Bike Pedals
Not a click, but a magnet. A steel plate goes under the shoe and is attached via the three holes of a road shoe. MAGPED states that the foot comes free sideways with almost no resistance and, in an emergency, upward as well. For the Road 2, the manufacturer names magnets with 200 newtons as suitable for riders from about 45 kilograms. According to MAGPED, the pair weighs 264 grams with a steel axle and 214 grams with a titanium axle.
The manufacturer itself names one limitation. Because there is no fixed connection, the foot can come loose unintentionally at any time, depending on dirt, foot position and the direction of pull. This is worth bearing in mind when riding out of the saddle on a steep climb.
How we would choose
You commute, ride a trekking bike or are unsure whether clipping in suits you at all? Then a dual-sided pedal with an SPD side, plus a shoe with a recessed cleat. On a gravel bike or mountain bike, you can then move on to a pure SPD pedal with an adjustable spring.
On a road bike, there is little way around three holes. If you are afraid of falling over there, weigh up a Keo-compatible pedal with the softest spring against the magnetic pedal. The magnetic pedal costs considerably more. But it also holds less firmly, and that is exactly the point.
One last tip: cleats wear out, especially from walking. If unclipping suddenly becomes difficult or sticky, it is often down to worn cleats, not the spring.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between SPD and Look Keo?
SPD uses shoes with two threaded holes and small cleats recessed into the sole, so you can walk almost normally and usually clip in on either side. Look Keo needs three holes and a large plastic cleat, clips in from one side only and offers a wider contact area. You cannot mix them.
How do I adjust the release tension on clipless pedals?
On good pedals, with a screw on the spring. Look states 8 Nm for the softest spring, about 4 kilograms of release force, and 20 Nm for the hardest, around 10 kilograms. The manufacturer's advice: when in doubt, the weaker setting. Practice the first few times while stationary, leaning against a wall.
Do clipless pedals give you more power?
Less than many people think. The claim that you can also pull up with clipless pedals hardly holds up in studies; on average, you do not ride more efficiently than on flat pedals. Only in a sprint can you briefly put more power into the crank. The gain is that your foot stays firmly in place and does not slip off in the wet.
How do magnetic pedals work?
A steel plate goes under the shoe and is attached via the three holes of a road shoe. MAGPED states that the foot comes free sideways with almost no resistance and, in an emergency, upward as well. The manufacturer itself names the limitation that the foot can come loose unintentionally at any time, for example when riding out of the saddle on a climb.
What does float mean on clipless pedals?
Float describes how far your heel can rotate while clipped in before the pedal releases. A few degrees of play are easier on the knees. For its beginner cleat X-Track Easy, Look specifies 6 degrees of float and a 13-degree release angle.
Why is the clipless pedal suddenly hard to release?
Often it is due to worn cleats, not the spring. Cleats wear mainly from walking. If unclipping becomes difficult or sticky, check the cleats under the shoe first before adjusting the spring tension.
Sources
- LOOK Cycle: Keo Blade, spring tensions and release force
- LOOK Cycle: Keo Classic 3
- LOOK Cycle: Cleat X-Track Easy
- MAGPED: ROAD2
- German Wikipedia: Bicycle pedal, section on clipless pedals (with references to studies)
- RADfahren: Flat or clipless pedal?
Where to buy
- ROCKBROS Fahrradpedale Alu 2 in 1 SPDView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- SPD-Klickpedale und Plattformpedale 2-in-1 inkl. CleatsView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS SPD Fahrradpedale mit Einstellbarer SpannungView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- SPD Fahrradpedale 146g LOOK KEO KompatibelView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- Kohlefaser-SPD-Klickpedale für RennräderView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- MAGPED Road 2 Magnetic Safety Bike PedalsView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






