Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
If you only go to campsites on weekends, a portable chemical toilet such as the Thetford Porta Potti 345 will serve you well. If you camp off-grid and go days without seeing a dump station, you should choose a separating toilet. So the question is less which toilet is better than where you want to empty it.
Everything else follows from that. Capacity, weight, odor, even the holes you drill in the van.
Chemical or separating: where do the contents go?
A chemical toilet collects everything in a waste tank, and an additive binds odors and breaks down the contents. According to the German automobile club ADAC, the contents of this tank do not belong in a normal drain because of the chemical additives, but at a dump station at a campsite or motorhome site. With a separating toilet, urine runs into a canister at the front, and solids drop into a container with bedding material at the back. According to the ADAC, you can pour the urine into a regular toilet and dispose of the solids in household waste or on the compost, ideally wearing gloves.
When it comes to compost, a second look at the manual is worthwhile. For the Tiny, Separett names three routes: an approved composting facility, approved incineration, or storage in a ventilated container with a layer of soil for at least twelve months, and only then onto the garden compost. The manufacturer also advises asking your local environmental authority about the rules in your own municipality. This is not a formality. Local waste regulations differ from place to place.
Which additive can go into the tank?
This is an important part of the decision. The background report on the German Blauer Engel (Blue Angel) eco-label DE-UZ 84a classifies biocidal agents in sanitary additives as particularly problematic for sewage treatment plants and the environment because they are toxic to bacteria. According to the same report, some campsite operators now only allow products that are compatible with sewage treatment plants. The ADAC recommends microbiological additives and points out that Switzerland has banned sanitary fluids containing the biocide bronopol. Before a trip abroad, check what applies in the country you are traveling to, and when in doubt, choose a product with the Blauer Engel label.
A separating toilet needs no additive at all. Just bedding material, such as sawdust or coconut fiber, which according to the ADAC speeds up drying.
How many liters do two people need?
The capacity printed on the box is tempting. A 21-liter tank sounds like freedom. When full, the contents alone weigh a good 20 kilograms, and you carry that to the station. For a couple at a campsite, the 12 liters of the Porta Potti 345 are easier to handle, since you empty it on site anyway.
With separating toilets, the manufacturers count in days. For two people using the MiniLoo, Kildwick states roughly every two to three days for the 9.5-liter urine canister and four to six days for the solids container. For the Tiny with two people in continuous use, Separett states two to three emptyings of the urine canister per week, and the solids container after about two weeks. So the urine sets the pace, not the solids.
What do you need to install in the van?
A portable chemical toilet you simply set down, and that is it. Still, it should not travel unsecured. For the Porta Potti 565, Thetford offers a floor plate, and for the 165, 335 and 365 a hold-down kit; for the 345, the manufacturer’s overview lists none. In that case, plan on your own tie-down strap or a suitable niche in the furniture.
The Separett Tiny requires more planning: a vent pipe with a 50 mm outer diameter to the outside and power for the fan, which according to the manual has to run constantly. It draws 1.6 watts at 12 volts, which according to the manufacturer comes to 0.04 kWh per day. That is a good 3 amp-hours from the onboard battery, a manageable load for a leisure battery or a power station for the camper (in German). The Kildwick MiniLoo works without a fan or power in its basic version; versions with a fan and a siphon for external urine drainage are available separately.
Measure the niche before you buy, and do it with a sitting test in mind. Between the 32.4 cm seat height of the Porta Potti 345 and up to 45.2 cm on the Separett Tiny, there are almost 13 centimeters.
Five camping toilets according to manufacturer specs
| Model | Principle and capacity | Dimensions (H × W × D) and weight | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thetford Porta Potti 345 | Chemical, 12 l waste, 15 l flush water, piston pump | 33 × 38.3 × 42.7 cm, seat 32.4 cm, 3.8 kg | Couples at campsites, small vans |
| Thetford Porta Potti 565E | Chemical, 21 l waste, 15 l flush water, electric flush | 44.8 × 38.8 × 45 cm, seat 44.3 cm, 5.0 kg | Families, caravans, anyone who wants a normal seat height |
| Dometic 976 | Chemical, about 18 l waste, 8 l flush water, push-button flush | 38.7 × 33.4 × 38.7 cm, just under 5 kg | Anyone looking for a large tank on a small footprint |
| Kildwick MiniLoo | Separating, 9.5 l urine, about 12 uses for solids | 44.5 × 33.7 × 38.4 cm, about 8 kg, wood | DIY van builders who want to do without power |
| Separett Tiny (urine canister) | Separating, 7.1 l urine, 14.5 l solids, 12 V fan | 47 × 39.8 × 49.7 cm, seat 44 to 45.2 cm, 8.5 kg | Long-term travelers with a permanent installation |
Thetford Porta Potti 345
The mid-size model in the Thetford range, with a 12-liter waste tank, 15 liters of flush water and a piston pump. Unlike the 145 and 165 models with a bellows pump, it has a level indicator for the waste tank. According to Thetford, all Porta Pottis can bear up to 120 kg in normal use. The seat height of 32.4 cm is low; if you have knee problems, you are better off looking one size up.
Thetford Porta Potti 565E
With a seat height of 44.3 cm, sitting here feels like sitting on a toilet at home. The waste tank holds 21 liters, both tanks have a level indicator, and flushing is electric via a battery-powered pump. For a fixed place in the vehicle, a floor plate is available as an accessory. With an empty weight of 5 kg and 21 liters in the tank, though, hauling it to the station is no stroll in the park.
Dometic 976
Dometic specifies a waste tank of about 18 liters with only 8 liters of flush water. You flush at the push of a button instead of pumping continuously, and a level indicator warns you before it overflows. More room for the contents, less water for flushing. If you flush sparingly, you have to go to the station less often than the tank size alone would suggest.
Kildwick MiniLoo
A separating toilet in a wooden housing, fully assembled, with a 9.5-liter urine canister and a magnetic seat. Kildwick rates the seat for up to 150 kg and the lid, used as a stool, for up to 100 kg. The housing is untreated; according to the manufacturer, it must be oiled or varnished before use.
Separett Tiny
The Tiny from Sweden is more of an installation than an accessory. The fan runs constantly and vents the air outside through the pipe, and the logo lights up red when the 7.1-liter urine canister is full. The solids container holds 14.5 liters and is lined with compostable bags. Separett grants a five-year warranty on manufacturing and material defects. But it cannot be done without a hole in the wall or floor.
How we would decide
- Campsite, two people, small van: Thetford Porta Potti 345, plus an additive with the Blauer Engel label.
- Family or caravan with a fixed niche: Porta Potti 565E, because of the seat height and the floor plate.
- Off-grid camping without power, DIY build: Kildwick MiniLoo.
- Long trips, permanent installation with ventilation: Separett Tiny.
- A large tank on a small footprint: Dometic 976.
A word about the typical bad buy. For a short trip where you empty at the campsite, we think a separating toilet is more effort than it is worth. Conversely, when camping off-grid, a large chemical toilet becomes a tank you have to haul too often. If you are thinking about power in your van anyway, you will also find advice on the compressor cooler (in German) on our site.
Frequently asked questions
Where do you empty a camping toilet?
According to the German automobile club ADAC, the tank of a chemical toilet belongs at a dump station because of the additives, not in a normal drain. With a separating toilet, the urine can go into a regular toilet and the solids into household waste. Separett names strict routes for composting; ask your local environmental authority.
Which additive can go into a chemical toilet?
The German Blauer Engel (Blue Angel) eco-label classifies biocidal agents in sanitary additives as problematic for sewage treatment plants, and some campsites now only allow additives that are compatible with treatment plants. The ADAC recommends microbiological additives, and Switzerland has banned products containing bronopol. When in doubt, choose a product with the Blauer Engel label.
How large should the tank be for two people?
A 21-liter tank sounds like freedom, but when full, the contents alone weigh a good 20 kilograms that you carry to the station. At a campsite, the 12 liters of the Porta Potti 345 are easier to handle. With separating toilets, the urine canister sets the pace, about every two to three days with the Kildwick MiniLoo.
Does a separating toilet need power?
That depends on the model. The Separett Tiny needs a fan that runs constantly, drawing 1.6 watts at 12 volts, plus a vent pipe to the outside. The Kildwick MiniLoo works without a fan or power in its basic version. The Tiny cannot be installed without a hole in the wall or floor.
What should you consider when installing a camping toilet in a van?
Measure the niche with a sitting test in mind: between the 32.4 cm seat height of the Porta Potti 345 and up to 45.2 cm on the Separett Tiny, there are almost 13 centimeters. No toilet should travel unsecured. Thetford offers a floor plate for the 565, for example; for the 345, the overview lists none.
Is a separating toilet worth it for a short trip?
For a short trip where you empty at the campsite, we think a separating toilet is more effort than it is worth. It needs bedding material, planning and, with the Separett Tiny, a permanent installation. Conversely, when camping off-grid, a large chemical toilet becomes a tank you have to haul too often.
Sources
- Thetford: Portable toilets
- Thetford: Portable toilets, technical data 2026 (PDF)
- Thetford: Porta Potti 500 series
- Dometic: 976
- Kildwick: MiniLoo dry separating toilet
- Separett: User manual for the Tiny with urine canister, item 1270 (PDF)
- ADAC: The camping toilet explained
- Blauer Engel: Background report DE-UZ 84a and b, sanitary additives compatible with sewage treatment plants (PDF)
- Blauer Engel: Sanitary additives for camping toilets
Where to buy
- Thetford Porta Potti 345Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Thetford Porta Potti 565ECheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dometic 976Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kildwick MiniLooCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Separett Tiny (Urinkanister)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
