Black Friday week from 19.11.: our pick in each buying guide
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,745 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Buying a cutting plotter: cutting width, blades, mat and software subscription explained. Cricut Maker 5, Joy Xtra, Silhouette Cameo 5 and Brother ScanNCut.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026

Editorial selection based on research, not tested by us. Reasons and limitations are in the text.

Contents10 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A cutting plotter that is too small for your own projects is an annoyance every single time. Window vinyl, heat transfer vinyl for T-shirts, occasionally fabric: for that you need a 30-centimeter cutting width and a rotary blade. That is why, in many cases, the search ends with the Cricut Maker 5. For cards and stickers, the small Silhouette Portrait 4 is enough, at a much lower price.

Six cutting plotters you can find on Amazon in 2026

ModelCutting widthWithout matMaterial thicknessWho it’s forOffer (affiliate link)
Cricut Maker 530.5 cm (Smart Materials)yes, Smart Materials only, up to 3.6 mup to 3 mmVersatile crafters, fabric tooAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Cricut Maker 429.7 cm (Smart Materials)yes, Smart Materials only, up to 3.6 mup to 2.4 mmAnyone who finds the predecessor in a bundleAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Cricut Joy Xtra21.6 cmyes, Smart Materials onlythin materialsCards, stickers, small vinyl projectsAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Silhouette Cameo 5 Alpha30.5 cmyes, material with backing, up to 4.9 mup to 3 mmVinyl and heat transfer vinyl without a subscriptionAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Silhouette Portrait 421.6 cmyes, material with backingthin materialsGetting started on a small budgetAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Brother ScanNCut SDX135029.7 cmno, mat as standardup to 3 mmSewing, quilting, scanning without a PCAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Want a second opinion before buying?Ask via WhatsApp

What’s behind the columns

All the machines here cut vinyl, heat transfer vinyl and paper. They differ in four points that tend to get lost in the brochure.

Around 30 centimeters of cutting width is the standard for hobby machines; compact models manage about 21 centimeters. That is enough for A4. Lettering across an entire rear window is not.

Normally, the material sticks to a cutting mat. Without a mat, it only works with vinyl on backing paper, and with Cricut exclusively with the company’s own „Smart Materials“ line. So with Cricut, you still cut inexpensive roll material from other manufacturers on the mat.

Fabric requires a rotary blade or a special fabric blade. For chipboard, leather or balsa wood up to around 3 millimeters, you need a strong blade and enough pressure. Some blades are included, others cost extra.

That leaves the software, and the subscription is often misunderstood. You control the machine from a computer or via an app, and all three manufacturers offer free basic software. Subscriptions mainly concern templates and fonts, not the machine itself. According to the manufacturer, Cricut Design Space is free; the Cricut Access subscription unlocks the large library of designs and fonts. Silhouette Studio is available as a free Basic Edition; according to Silhouette, you buy upgrades such as the Designer Edition once, and only from this level can you load your own designs as SVG. Brother describes its CanvasWorkspace software as free.

Cricut Maker 5: the widest range

Cricut’s current top model. Cricut lists 13 tools, including a rotary blade for fabric and the Knife Blade for materials up to 3 millimeters. On the large mat, the Maker 5 cuts 29.2 × 60.3 centimeters, and with Smart Vinyl up to 3.6 meters in one piece. The connection is via USB-C or Bluetooth. Two limitations remain: several tools cost extra, and without a mat it only works with Cricut material. On Amazon, the Maker 5 is currently only available in a bundle with accessories (Essential, Deluxe or Ultimate Bundle); our buy button leads to the Ultimate Bundle.

Cricut Maker 4: the predecessor in a bundle

The Maker 4 is still available on Amazon, usually as a bundle with material. It uses the same 13 tools, but cuts Smart Materials only 29.7 centimeters wide, and Cricut rates it for material up to 2.4 millimeters. It is also larger and heavier than its successor. It becomes interesting when the bundle is noticeably cheaper than a comparable Maker 5.

Cricut Joy Xtra: small, but with limits

According to Cricut, the Joy Xtra is only around 32 centimeters long. It cuts Smart Materials 21.6 centimeters wide, single designs up to 1.2 meters long, and about A4 on the mat. It handles three tools: cutting, writing and foil embossing. Fabric, leather and chipboard are not its territory. It is enough for birthday cards and mug stickers. As a long-term hobby, it often gets cramped.

Silhouette Cameo 5 Alpha: lots of area, no subscription required

According to Silhouette, the new Alpha generation of the Cameo cuts 30.5 × 61 centimeters on the mat, and vinyl with backing paper without a mat up to 4.9 meters long. Two tool holders, a self-adjusting AutoBlade and material up to 3 millimeters are part of the package. An electrostatic mat is included as an accessory; according to the manufacturer, it holds thin materials up to 0.5 millimeters without adhesive. Lots of vinyl and heat transfer vinyl from any roll material? Then you have more freedom here than with Cricut. Fabric requires a separate blade.

Silhouette Portrait 4: the affordable way in

Silhouette gives a cutting width of 21.6 centimeters for the Portrait 4, and up to 21.6 × 30.5 centimeters on the mat. Without a mat, it handles vinyl with backing in long lengths. Bluetooth and USB are included. In terms of price, it belongs to the entry-level range and costs significantly less on Amazon than the large machines. The compromise you pay is the cutting width.

Brother ScanNCut SDX1350: the plotter with a scanner

Brother takes its own path. A 600 dpi scanner, a touchscreen, operation entirely without a computer. According to the manufacturer, a sensor detects the material thickness and adjusts the automatic blade itself; it cuts up to 3 millimeters at a width of 297 millimeters. For appliqués on the sewing machine or cut quilt pieces, this is the most coherent concept. Long lengths of vinyl, however, are not much fun with the mat.

Which plotter for which project?

  • Vinyl, heat transfer vinyl, paper and occasionally fabric: Cricut Maker 5. It covers the widest range of materials, provided you budget for additional tools.
  • Lots of vinyl from the roll, without being tied to one material manufacturer: Silhouette Cameo 5 Alpha.
  • Cards and stickers up to A4, small budget: Silhouette Portrait 4. The Joy Xtra is the alternative if you would rather stay in the Cricut world.
  • Sewing and quilting: Brother ScanNCut SDX1350.
  • Engraving wood or acrylic as the main purpose: A plotter only engraves the surface. In that case a laser engraver is a better fit, and for three-dimensional parts a 3D printer.

And consumables belong in the calculation. Mats lose their stickiness, blades get dull, Smart Materials only come from Cricut. If you cut a lot, you notice it in your bank account sooner than on the machine.

Frequently asked questions

What cutting width does a cutting plotter need?

Around 30 centimeters is the standard for hobby machines; compact models manage about 21 centimeters. That is enough for A4, but not for lettering across an entire rear window. For window vinyl, heat transfer vinyl for T-shirts and occasional fabric, you need the 30 centimeters.

Can you cut with a plotter without a cutting mat?

Only with vinyl on backing paper, and with Cricut exclusively with the company's own "Smart Materials" line. So with Cricut, you still cut inexpensive roll material from other manufacturers on the mat. The Silhouette Cameo 5 Alpha cuts material with backing without a mat up to 4.9 meters long.

Do you need a subscription for a cutting plotter?

No. All three manufacturers offer free basic software. Subscriptions mainly concern templates and fonts: Cricut Access unlocks the large design library. With Silhouette, you buy upgrades such as the Designer Edition once, and only from this level can you load your own SVG designs.

What is the difference between the Cricut Maker 5 and Maker 4?

Both use the same 13 tools. The Maker 5 cuts Smart Materials 30.5 cm wide and material up to 3 mm, while the Maker 4 only manages 29.7 cm and, according to Cricut, up to 2.4 mm. The predecessor is also larger and heavier. It becomes interesting when the bundle is noticeably cheaper.

Which plotter is suitable for sewing and quilting?

The Brother ScanNCut SDX1350 has a 600 dpi scanner and a touchscreen and works entirely without a computer. According to the manufacturer, a sensor detects the material thickness and adjusts the blade automatically. The concept suits appliqués and quilt pieces; long lengths of vinyl are not much fun with the mat.

What follow-up costs does a cutting plotter have?

Consumables belong in the calculation: mats lose their stickiness, blades get dull, and Smart Materials only come from Cricut. With the Cricut Maker 5, several tools also cost extra. If you cut a lot, you notice it in your bank account sooner than on the machine.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Still undecided?

Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.

Share this guide