Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Measure first, then order. If you pick LED recessed spotlights by looks and only discover while drilling that there are just four centimeters of space above the drywall, you end up buying twice. For most rooms with a shallow ceiling, the swiveling Paulmann Nova Plus Coin set fits, with 45 millimeters of installation depth and IP65 protection; if you want especially color-accurate light and are drilling 68-millimeter holes anyway, take a look at LEDVANCE Spot Fix and SLV New Tria 68.
Tape measure before catalog: hole size and cavity first
Two numbers decide whether a spot fits your ceiling at all: the cutout (manufacturers often call it the „installation diameter“ or „ceiling cutout“) and the installation depth. Across the five models here, the holes range from 68 to 83 millimeters and the depths from 38 to 70 millimeters. That is almost a factor of two.
If you already have holes from old halogen spots, the hole size is set. A 68 mm hole cannot be made smaller, and one that is too large can only be hidden with a cover ring. In a suspended ceiling in a new build, 50 millimeters of cavity is often no problem. Under a timber joist ceiling with battens, things look different, and that is exactly where flat spots with an LED module instead of a GU10 bulb help. Paulmann lists a cavity depth in addition to the installation depth; plan with the larger value.
Watch out for insulation. LEDVANCE and Brumberg state explicitly in their data sheets that the spotlights must not be covered with thermal insulation material. If there is mineral wool above the ceiling, you need clearance. LEDVANCE even offers a dedicated spacer as an accessory for this; with the other manufacturers, ask before you buy.
Swiveling, dimming, color temperature: what you cannot change later
A swiveling spot pays off wherever light should not just fall straight down: onto a picture, onto the countertop, onto a textured wall. The three swiveling models here each tilt by 30 degrees. If all you want is general lighting, you do not need that.
There are three ways to dim. Traditionally with a leading-edge or trailing-edge wall dimmer; in that case the dimmer has to match the fixture and its minimum load has to be reached, as SLV explicitly points out. More convenient is Paulmann’s step dimming („3-Step-Dim“), which works via the existing light switch. And with Brumberg, the separate converter determines whether and how the light can be dimmed.
On color temperature, the German lighting association licht.de classifies warm white as between 2,700 and 3,300 kelvin and recommends warm color temperatures of up to 3,300 kelvin for the evening. All the models below fall within that range. The bigger difference lies in the color rendering index: LEDVANCE and SLV state Ra 90, Paulmann and Brumberg more than 80. The higher the value, the more natural colors look under the light, and above the kitchen counter that matters more than in the hallway.
In the bathroom, the safety zone counts, not the label
„IP44“ on the box does not yet mean the spot may go above the shower. According to licht.de’s overview of the German standard DIN VDE 0100-701, zone 1 covers the area above the bathtub or shower up to a height of 2.25 meters. There, the standard requires at least IPX4 plus safety extra-low voltage, meaning no more than 25 volts AC or 60 volts DC. A 230-volt spot is therefore ruled out, no matter how well sealed it is. Zone 2 extends 60 centimeters further and also requires at least IPX4. Outside these zones, the standard does not prescribe a higher protection rating.
Do not do the wiring yourself. Under § 13 of the German low-voltage connection ordinance (Niederspannungsanschlussverordnung), work on the installation beyond the main service fuse may only be carried out, apart from the grid operator, by installation companies registered in an installer directory. In the bathroom, that is not even a question.
Five LED recessed spotlights compared
| Model | Cutout / installation depth | Light and protection rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paulmann Nova Plus Coin 93682 (set of 3) | 83 mm / 45 mm | 470 lm each, 2,700 K, Ra > 80, IP65, swivels 30°, dimmable | Shallow ceilings, bathroom outside zone 1, kitchen |
| Paulmann Cole Coin 94870 (set of 3) | 80 mm / 70 mm | 470 lm each, 2,700 K, Ra > 80, IP44, fixed, 3-step dimming | Dimming without a new dimmer, sufficiently deep ceiling |
| LEDVANCE Spot Fix IP44 8 W 927 DIM | 68 mm / 50 mm | up to 640 lm, 2,700 K, Ra 90, IP44 on the room side, fixed, trailing-edge dimming | Existing 68 mm holes, bathroom and hallway |
| SLV New Tria 68 1007389 | 68 mm / 40 mm | 750 lm, 3,000 K, Ra 90, IP20, swivels 30°, dimmable | Living spaces, accents on walls and pictures |
| Brumberg Seven-R 12361023 | 68 mm / 38 mm | 740 lm, 3,000 K, Ra > 80, IP20, swivels 30°, converter required | Very shallow ceilings, planning with an electrician |
Paulmann Nova Plus Coin: the flat all-rounder
The set of three combines 45 millimeters of installation depth, a 30-degree swivel range and, according to Paulmann, IP65 protection against water jets. The flat LED module („Coin“) is replaceable. The drawback is in the details: the cutout measures 83 millimeters, so old 68 mm holes will not fit.
Paulmann Cole Coin: dimming with your old switch
Cole is meant for anyone who does not want to retrofit a dimmer. According to Paulmann, the fixture switches between three brightness levels using a normal light switch. In return, it is fixed and needs 70 millimeters of installation depth. In some older ceilings, that is too much.
LEDVANCE Spot Fix IP44: trade-grade spot for 68 mm holes
This spot comes from LEDVANCE’s professional range. A switch on the external driver lets you choose between 640, 480 and 320 lumens, which is handy if a hallway should not be too bright. Ra 90, trailing-edge dimming and a five-year warranty, according to the manufacturer. It does not swivel, and the IP44 rating applies on the room side.
SLV New Tria 68: lots of light, little depth
At 750 lumens, the New Tria 68 is the brightest single spot in this comparison, with just 40 millimeters of installation depth. SLV states Ra 90 and lists compatible dimmers from various switch manufacturers. With IP20, it is not made for the bathroom. In the living room, where a spot is supposed to hit a picture, it belongs on the shortlist.
Brumberg Seven-R: flat, but only with a converter
At 38 millimeters, it has the shallowest installation depth here. However, the Seven-R runs on 350 milliamps of direct current and needs a separate converter, which Brumberg offers as a switched version or with trailing-edge dimming. According to the data sheet, the ceiling may be no more than 13 millimeters thick. A solution for planning with an electrician, less so for a quick swap.
How we would decide
- New holes, shallow ceiling, also for the bathroom outside the shower: Paulmann Nova Plus Coin.
- No dimmer on the wall and enough depth: Paulmann Cole Coin.
- Old 68 mm holes in the hallway or bathroom, fixed light is enough: LEDVANCE Spot Fix IP44.
- Living space with accent lighting on a picture or wall: SLV New Tria 68.
- Less than 40 millimeters of cavity: Brumberg Seven-R with a matching converter.
How many spots a room needs, and whether a single fixture might be enough after all, is covered in our ceiling light guide. For lighting at the vanity, take a look at our guide to illuminated bathroom mirrors.
Frequently asked questions
Which dimensions matter for LED recessed spotlights?
Two numbers decide: the cutout and the installation depth. Across the five models, the holes range from 68 to 83 millimeters and the depths from 38 to 70. Existing holes from old halogen spots set the hole size, because a 68 mm hole cannot be made smaller.
What if there is hardly any space above the ceiling?
Under a timber joist ceiling with battens, flat spots with an LED module instead of a GU10 bulb help. The Brumberg Seven-R gets by with 38 millimeters but needs a separate converter. Paulmann lists a cavity depth in addition to the installation depth; plan with the larger value.
Can recessed spotlights be covered with insulation?
No. LEDVANCE and Brumberg state explicitly that the spotlights must not be covered with thermal insulation material. If there is mineral wool above the ceiling, you need clearance; LEDVANCE offers a spacer as an accessory for this.
How can LED recessed spotlights be dimmed?
Traditionally with a wall dimmer, which has to match the fixture and reach its minimum load. With the Cole Coin, Paulmann offers step dimming via the existing light switch. With Brumberg, the separate converter determines whether and how the light can be dimmed.
Which recessed spotlights are allowed above the shower?
Under the German standard DIN VDE 0100-701, zone 1 above the bathtub or shower up to a height of 2.25 meters requires at least IPX4 plus safety extra-low voltage. A 230-volt spot is ruled out there, no matter how well sealed it is. Zone 2 extends 60 centimeters further and also requires IPX4.
Which color temperature and color rendering make sense?
licht.de recommends warm color temperatures of up to 3,300 kelvin for the evening, and all models fall within that range. The bigger difference lies in the color rendering index: LEDVANCE and SLV state Ra 90, Paulmann and Brumberg more than 80. Above the kitchen counter, that matters more than in the hallway.
Sources
- Paulmann: Nova Plus Coin base set 93682
- Paulmann: Cole Coin set of 3 94870
- LEDVANCE: Spot Fix P 8W 927 PS DIM IP44
- SLV: New Tria 68 1007389 data sheet
- SLV: New Tria 68 product page
- Brumberg: Seven-R 12361023 data sheet
- licht.de: Bathroom installation, safety zones under DIN VDE 0100-701
- licht.de: Color temperature
- German low-voltage connection ordinance (NAV), § 13
Where to buy
- Paulmann Nova Plus Coin 93682 3er-SetCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Paulmann Cole Coin 94870 3er-Set IP44Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- LEDVANCE Spot Fix IP44 8 W 927 DIMCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- SLV New Tria 68 3000 K 38° rundCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Brumberg Seven-R 12361023Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
