Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
In the end, a milk frother is decided by the sink, not the foam. If you froth every morning, first find out whether the jug is dishwasher-safe. That is why we consider an induction frother with a removable stainless steel jug such as the Severin Spuma Lite the more sensible choice for most households than a model with heating built permanently into the base of the jug.
The rest is a question of quantity, the type of milk and the coffee that goes underneath.
Two designs, one difference at the sink
Classic electric frothers heat the milk via a heating element in the base of the jug. The inside of the jug then usually has a nonstick coating, and it does not belong in water. With Melitta’s Cremio, for example, only the lid with the whisk may go in the dishwasher according to the manufacturer; the container itself is wiped out with a damp cloth. That works as long as you do it right away. Dried-on milk at the bottom is a chore.
Induction is different. Here, the coil sits in the base unit, and the jug is a plain stainless steel cup with no electronics. Severin and Sage explicitly approve it for the dishwasher. According to Severin, induction keeps the milk from burning. The design has no real drawback; it is just that far from every manufacturer offers it.
What the capacity figures really mean
Manufacturers often give two figures. The smaller one applies to foam. According to Nespresso, the Aeroccino 4 handles at most 120 ml of milk for foam, but 240 ml of hot milk. For two large latte macchiatos, that gets tight.
Cold foam, oat, hot chocolate
Iced coffee and cold brew need a function that stirs without heating. All six models below have one; on the Cremio, it is hidden behind a longer press of the button.
Plant-based drinks are trickier. Oat, soy and almond froth very differently depending on the brand; Sage itself writes that not all soy drinks form foam. A dedicated program like WMF’s is a plus, but not a promise. And the hot chocolate function? Severin, Bodum and WMF have it. If you only drink cappuccino, you pay for it anyway.
Six milk frothers, the key specs side by side
| Model | Heating and foam | Capacity according to manufacturer | Dishwasher | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Severin Spuma Lite SM 3589 | Induction, warm and cold, chocolate function | Foam up to 220 ml, milk up to 400 ml | Stainless steel container | Households with two coffee drinkers |
| Nespresso Aeroccino 4 | warm and cold, hot milk | Foam up to 120 ml, milk up to 240 ml | all parts except base | Capsule users with small cups |
| Sage the Milk Café | Induction, two discs, cold stirring | for about three cups | Jug, lid, discs (top rack) | Several cups in one go |
| WMF Lono Glas | warm and cold, hot chocolate, program for plant-based drinks | Glass jug 250 ml | Jug, lid, seal, whisk unit | Oat and soy drinkers |
| Bodum Bistro Barista 11901 | warm and cold, heating disc for milk and hot chocolate | up to 400 ml | Container, lid, discs | Large mugs, hot chocolate too |
| Melitta Cremio | Heating function in the container, warm and cold | Foam 100 to 150 ml, milk up to 250 ml | only lid with whisk | Occasional users |
Severin Spuma Lite SM 3589
The little sibling of the Spuma 700 series heats by induction, froths warm and cold and melts chocolate. Severin specifies up to 220 ml of milk for foam and up to 400 ml for heating. The stainless steel container is dishwasher-safe. The manufacturer’s page does not mention plant-based drinks. Severin currently lists the larger Spuma 700 Plus as sold out; as a rule, the Lite version is enough anyway.
Nespresso Aeroccino 4
The classic next to the capsule machine. According to the manual, foam takes about 80 seconds and hot milk about 150. Apart from the base, all parts may go in the dishwasher at a maximum of 70 degrees. Nespresso explicitly lists soy, almond and oat drinks as possible. The real limit is the 120 ml of foam: fine for one cup of cappuccino, too little for a family.
Sage the Milk Café
The largest in the field. Sage relies on induction and includes two discs, one for firm cappuccino foam and one for fine latte foam; on top of that comes a cold-stir function for iced drinks. According to the manual, the jug, lid, measuring cup and discs are dishwasher-safe (top rack), though Sage still recommends washing the discs by hand. Upper price bracket. That only pays off if you regularly froth for several cups.
WMF Lono Glas
With WMF, you can see what is happening. The 250 ml glass jug, lid, seal and whisk unit can handle the dishwasher; the housing is only wiped down. According to WMF, the Lono Glas is the only device here with a dedicated function for oat, soy and almond drinks. At 650 watts, it carries the highest power rating in the field. WMF does not state the heating technology.
Bodum Bistro Barista 11901
The Bodum holds up to 400 ml and works with two discs: one for frothing, warm or cold, and one for heating milk and hot chocolate. According to Bodum, the container, lid and discs are dishwasher-safe, and the inside of the stainless steel container has a nonstick coating. Bodum gives no information on plant-based drinks. The suffix EURO in the item number matters, because retailers list different specs for other country versions.
Melitta Cremio
For years the simple way in. Melitta specifies 100 to 150 ml of foam and up to 250 ml of warm milk; cold foam works with a longer press of the button. According to the manufacturer, oat, soy and lactose-free milk work, and for firm foam Melitta recommends milk high in fat and protein. The weak point is cleaning. Only the lid with the whisk may go in the dishwasher.
Which frother suits which morning
- One or two cups a day, little effort at the sink: Severin Spuma Lite. Induction, dishwasher, enough capacity for two.
- Nespresso machine already at home, usually one cup: Aeroccino 4. Matches visually and is enough for cappuccino.
- Oat or soy drink every day: WMF Lono Glas with its dedicated function. Still comes down to the brand in your fridge.
- Several people, lots of milk: Sage the Milk Café. Oversized for singles.
- Large mugs and the occasional hot chocolate: Bodum Bistro Barista with 400 ml and its own heating disc.
- Rarely foam, careful cleaning no problem: Melitta Cremio.
No machine yet? The basics are in the guide to capsule machines. Many fully automatic coffee machines froth the milk themselves, so a separate frother is mainly of interest there for cold foam. And if you use an espresso machine with a portafilter, the steam wand is usually already the more precise tool.
When automatic milk in a fully automatic machine pays off is shown in the guide fully automatic coffee machines up to 500 euros; without a milk system, there is the class up to 300 euros.
If you drink several glasses a day, choose the milk system first; that is explained in the guide to the fully automatic coffee machine for latte macchiato.
According to retailer information, the WMF Lumero has 500 W and four programs for warm and cold foam as well as hot milk, and handles foam up to 150 ml or milk up to 250 ml.
Milk foam right at the machine comes from the steam nozzle of the De’Longhi Dedica; our experience is in the long-term review of the Dedica.
Frequently asked questions
Which milk frother is dishwasher-safe?
On induction models, the jug is a plain stainless steel cup with no electronics; Severin and Sage explicitly approve it for the dishwasher. On models with the heating built into the base of the jug, such as the Melitta Cremio, only the lid with the whisk may go in, and the container is wiped out with a damp cloth.
What is the difference between induction and a heating element in a milk frother?
Classic frothers heat via a heating element in the base of the jug; the inside of the jug usually has a nonstick coating and must not be submerged in water. With induction, the coil sits in the base unit. According to Severin, this keeps the milk from burning, and the jug can be cleaned in the dishwasher.
How much milk foam can a frother make?
Manufacturers often give two figures; the smaller one applies to foam. According to Nespresso, the Aeroccino 4 handles at most 120 ml of milk for foam, but 240 ml of hot milk. For two large latte macchiatos, that gets tight; the Severin Spuma Lite froths up to 220 ml.
Do oat and soy drinks froth in a milk frother?
That depends heavily on the brand; Sage itself writes that not all soy drinks form foam. According to WMF, the WMF Lono Glas is the only device in this comparison with a dedicated function for oat, soy and almond drinks. That is a plus, but not a promise.
Can a milk frother make cold foam?
All six models in the comparison have a function that stirs without heating, as iced coffee and cold brew require. On the Melitta Cremio, it is hidden behind a longer press of the button. The Sage the Milk Café calls it cold stirring for iced drinks.
Do you need a milk frother with a fully automatic coffee machine?
Many fully automatic coffee machines froth the milk themselves, so a separate frother is mainly of interest there for cold foam. If you use an espresso machine with a portafilter, the steam wand is usually already the more precise tool.
Sources
- Severin: Spuma Lite induction milk frother
- Severin: overview of milk frothers with availability
- Nespresso: Aeroccino 4 user manual
- Sage: the Milk Café
- Sage: the Milk Café user manual
- WMF: Lono Glas milk frother
- Bodum: Bistro Barista milk frother 400 ml
- Melitta: Cremio milk frother
- WMF Lumero milk frother: product details
Where to buy
- Severin Spuma Lite SM 3589Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Nespresso Aeroccino 4Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sage the Milk CaféCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- WMF Lono Glas MilchaufschäumerCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bodum Bistro Barista 11901Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Melitta Cremio MilchaufschäumerCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- WMF Lumero MilchaufschäumerView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue
