Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A pool robot does not spend the winter in the pool. The real question comes after that: how full should the battery be, and how cold can it get in the shed? The manufacturers answer this in surprisingly different ways. If you want to keep the winter break as simple as possible, the Dolphin E20 serves you well among the devices compared here, because a corded device has no battery that ages over the winter. Among cordless models, we consider the Dolphin LIBERTY 400 less complicated than Ecovacs‘ ULTRAMARINE P1.
Which device suits your pool is covered in the pool robot guide.
In summer: clean the filter after every cycle
The most important care takes two minutes. Maytronics, Ecovacs and Zodiac say the same thing: take the robot out and rinse the filter right away, before the dirt dries on. Otherwise it clogs, and suction suffers.
On top of that, there is a monthly session. On the E20 and the LIBERTY, the ultra-fine filter panels should come out and go under the hose about once a month. If the fabric stays brown afterward, Maytronics says it is time for a replacement. Ecovacs is more specific with the P1: the 3-micron filter is considered a wear part and should be replaced every 150 operating hours. Three two-hour cycles a week over 20 swimming weeks add up to 120 hours, so roughly one filter per season. Replacement baskets in the Ecovacs shop cost in the low to mid double-digit euro range.
Every three to four months, Ecovacs also checks the impeller, drive track and gears. At Dolphin, the impeller appears in the troubleshooting list, not in the schedule. None of them recommends leaving the robot in the water permanently: Maytronics advises taking it out after each cycle, and Aiper names two weeks at a stretch as the limit for devices with an eco mode. To dry, the device belongs in the shade, not in the blazing sun at the edge of the pool.
Chlorine, pH, salt: when the robot stays out
The limits are in the manuals and are the same for the Dolphin and the P1: no more than 4 ppm chlorine, pH 7.0 to 7.8, no more than 5,000 ppm salt, water from 6 to 35 °C. Zodiac is stricter with its corded robots and states less than 3 mg/l free chlorine, pH 6.8 to 7.6 and at least 10 °C. Without measuring, these are just numbers, so a pH meter (in German) is part of the care routine.
When shocking, there is a clear rule. Zodiac prohibits operation during shock chlorination, and Maytronics wants the robot out of the pool when chemicals are added, until chlorine, pH and salt are right again. Liquid flocculants and clarifiers are completely off-limits for Dolphin because they clog and damage the filters.
Salt water up to 5,000 ppm is approved for Dolphin and the P1. According to Zodiac, however, freshly added salt must first dissolve completely. After taking the robot out, rinse it with fresh water; Maytronics advises this for chlorine and salt residue. If the device suddenly stops climbing, the cause is often the pool: Ecovacs and Maytronics name incorrect water values and algae that make walls slippery before you reach for customer service.
In the fall: clean first, then shock
Before the winter break, Maytronics recommends several cycles so that leaves and organic residue do not sit in the pool for months, followed by a chlorine shock including algaecide. Because the robot must not be in the water during shocking, that sets the order. Start early. According to Maytronics, you winterize as soon as the water drops permanently below 15 °C, and that is exactly where the safety sheet for the corded devices mentions weaker climbing performance. So it is better to do the walls in September.
One thing does not fit together: Ecovacs prohibits running the P1 while the pool filter is running. If you keep circulation going through the sand filter system in the fall, you have to switch it off for the cycle.
Then comes the inspection. For the drive track and brush rollers, Ecovacs specifies a check every twelve months or before storage; Maytronics at least once a year including the cable and motor, ideally at a specialist dealer. For Zodiac, the manual lists the filter, tracks and brushes every two years.
Five devices and their winter rules
| Model | Power | Storage according to the manufacturer | Battery in winter | Warranty | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dolphin E20 | Cable 15 m | 5 to 45 °C, protected from frost | no battery | 2 years | small pools up to 10 m, not fiberglass |
| Dolphin E10 | Cable 12 m | 5 to 45 °C | no battery | 2 years | above-ground pools up to 8 m, floor only |
| Dolphin LIBERTY 400 | Battery | −10 to 40 °C | charge to about 50 % | 3 years | no cable, cool storage location |
| ULTRAMARINE P1 | Battery | 5 to 45 °C, below 80 % humidity | every 3 months to 40 to 60 % | 2 years | frost-free basement, date in the calendar |
| Aiper Scuba V3 | Battery | no information online | charge before storing | 1 to 2 years | camera technology, read the manual first |
Dolphin E20
No charge level, no recharging dates, no battery that ends up taking the device with it. Before storage, all water has to come out, the filters go back in place clean, and the cable is coiled without kinks. If it does have kinks, Maytronics says it should lie stretched out in the sun for a day. The downside is in the table: according to the manual, it cannot tolerate frost, so the garden shed is out. The product sheet calls it unsuitable for smooth pools and fiberglass, and there is no timer or app.
Dolphin E10
The same care on a smaller scale, with a shorter cable. It only cleans the floor and is designed for above-ground pools. We have not read a dedicated winter instruction for it; Maytronics gives the 5 to 45 °C for the off-season in general terms.
Dolphin LIBERTY 400
The simplest battery rule here: charge to about 50 percent, store somewhere cool, fully charge after the break. The manual warns against heat and allows cold down to −10 °C. Because an article from the same manufacturer states 5 to 45 °C for the off-season, we would still store it frost-free. The charger is waterproof, so the wet robot can be connected to it. Charge only at 6 to 35 °C. The battery cannot be replaced.
ULTRAMARINE P1
The most winter work. According to the manual, Ecovacs wants the device fully charged before storage and, in the same section, brought to 40 to 60 percent every three months; otherwise, it says, an energy-saving mode could set in and damage the battery. That is contradictory; we would store it at about 50 percent and take the three months seriously. The storage temperature of 5 to 45 °C sits next to a value of −20 °C for the battery; the narrower one applies. Before charging, the port must be dry, and a distance of 3.5 m from the pool must be kept. The battery is not replaceable; according to the manual, the device must be disposed of at the end of its service life. Roller brushes, climbing rings and filter baskets are available in the Ecovacs shop.
Aiper Scuba V3
Aiper advises always charging the device before storing it and refers to the service manual for details. The manufacturer does not state temperature limits online, and the help pages give the warranty as one to two years. That leaves us without the numbers for planning the winter.
What the German Environment Agency says about the battery
The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) gives three general rules for lithium-ion batteries: above 40 °C the battery suffers even in storage, deep discharge should be avoided, and when garden tools are stored over the winter, they should be recharged after six months at the latest. That fits Maytronics‘ rule better than blanket charging before storage. More on the principle is in the article on storing power stations (in German). For the pool, that means: charge halfway in the fall, check in winter.
In spring: the first start-up
- Water first. Before the first cycle, adjust the values and, after shocking, wait until they are right.
- Fully charge the cordless device. According to the manual, this takes about four hours for the P1 and up to six for the LIBERTY, in the shade in each case and not in a cold garage.
- Check the filter, brushes and tracks while replacements can still arrive before the season.
- Below a water temperature of 6 °C, the robot stays out, even if the sun is tempting.
How we would decide
- Frost-free basement, small pool without fiberglass, little interest in battery care: Dolphin E20.
- Small above-ground pool, floor is enough: Dolphin E10.
- No cable wanted, cool storage location: Dolphin LIBERTY 400.
- Large pool, and the three-month charge is in the calendar: ULTRAMARINE P1.
- Interested in camera technology: Aiper Scuba V3, check the storage values in the manual first.
Whether the pool is taken down or covered in winter makes no difference to the robot. What the pool itself needs is in the above-ground pool guide.
Rust is an issue with steel-frame pools; what happened with ours is described in the review of the Bestway Power Steel pool.
Frequently asked questions
How often do you need to clean a pool robot's filter?
After every cycle, before the dirt dries on; Maytronics, Ecovacs and Zodiac agree on that. In addition, there is a monthly session for the filter panels of the E20 and LIBERTY. Ecovacs replaces the 3-micron filter of the P1 every 150 operating hours.
Which water values can a pool robot handle?
For the Dolphin and the P1, no more than 4 ppm chlorine, pH 7.0 to 7.8, no more than 5,000 ppm salt and water from 6 to 35 °C. Zodiac is stricter and states less than 3 mg/l free chlorine. When shocking and adding chemicals, the robot stays out.
How do you store a cordless pool robot in winter?
For the LIBERTY 400, charge to about 50 percent, store it somewhere cool and fully charge it after the break. For the P1, the battery should be brought to 40 to 60 percent every three months; otherwise, according to Ecovacs, damage may result. The German Environment Agency advises avoiding deep discharge.
Can a pool robot be stored in freezing conditions?
According to its manual, the Dolphin E20 cannot tolerate frost, so the garden shed is out. For the LIBERTY 400, the manual allows down to −10 °C, but an article from the same manufacturer states 5 to 45 °C. We would still store it frost-free.
What needs to be done in the fall before winterizing?
First run several cleaning cycles so that leaves do not sit in the pool for months, then a chlorine shock including algaecide. The robot must not be in the water during shocking. According to Maytronics, you winterize as soon as the water drops permanently below 15 °C, so it is better to do the walls in September.
What is part of the first start-up in spring?
First adjust the water values and, after shocking, wait until they are right. Then fully charge the cordless device: about four hours for the P1, up to six for the LIBERTY. Check the filter, brushes and tracks. Below a water temperature of 6 °C, the robot stays out.
Sources
- Maytronics: Dolphin E20, user manual
- Maytronics: Dolphin E20, product page
- Maytronics: Dolphin E20, product sheet
- Maytronics: Dolphin E10, product page
- Maytronics: Dolphin LIBERTY, operating instructions
- Maytronics: Dolphin LIBERTY 400, product page
- Maytronics: safety instructions for corded devices
- Maytronics: Preparing your pool for winter
- Maytronics: Leaving a pool robot in the pool permanently?
- Ecovacs: ULTRAMARINE P1, product page
- Ecovacs: ULTRAMARINE P1, manual
- Ecovacs: warranty
- Aiper: frequently asked questions
- Aiper: Scuba V3
- Zodiac: Voyager and CNX manual
- Zodiac: warnings for corded robots
- German Environment Agency: batteries and rechargeable batteries
Where to buy
- Dolphin E20Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dolphin E10Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dolphin LIBERTY 400Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- ULTRAMARINE P1View at EcovacsAvailable in Germany: EcovacsCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.deView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue
- Aiper Scuba V3Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
