Contents8 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Tuscany, the Amalfi Coast, Sicily: Italy is especially well suited to exploring by rental car. The big rental companies are present at all major airports, from Milan-Malpensa and Rome-Fiumicino to Naples, Catania and Palermo. Things can get expensive in the historic centers. And sometimes the bill only arrives by mail months later.
For coastal Tuscany, our visit report describes Camping St. Michael near Pisa (in German).
The ZTL trap
ZTL stands for „Zona a traffico limitato,“ restricted-traffic zones in many city centers. The driving bans apply at the times shown on the sign. According to ADAC, anyone who drives in without authorization risks a heavy fine. In some major cities, access to such areas also costs a fee, and according to the German Federal Foreign Office, Milan, Bologna and Palermo charge a congestion fee.
So park outside the historic center, in one of the signposted parking lots on the edge, and walk the last stretch in, even if the navigation system wants to guide you right up to the hotel.
Credit card and insurance
Without a credit card, nothing works. Really nothing. The deposit is blocked for the rental period, cash deposits are not possible, and debit and prepaid cards are not accepted. The card needs a sufficient limit and a PIN. You can rent from age 18, and under 25 many rental companies charge a surcharge. Because of the heavy traffic and narrow lanes, ADAC recommends collision damage cover and theft protection without a deductible.
| Component | Why it matters in Italy |
|---|---|
| Recommendation: rental car with collision damage cover without a deductible | heavy traffic, narrow lanes |
| Small rental car | historic centers and parking lots are tight |
| Rental car with ferry permission | register in advance for Elba, Ischia or Sardinia |
Tolls: always take a ticket
Highways with green signs are subject to tolls, according to ADAC Autovermietung at an average of about 7 cents per kilometer. There is no vignette. You take a ticket when you get on and pay when you get off, even if the barrier is already open. According to ADAC, anyone who arrives at the exit without a ticket pays a penalty fee and the highest possible amount.
At the exit, the lanes show how to pay: white for cash, blue for card, yellow for Telepass. Wrong lane? Then you can’t get through. According to ADAC, the expressways are toll-free, as are the A2 from Salerno to Reggio di Calabria on the mainland and everything on Sicily except the A20 Messina–Palermo and the A18 Messina–Catania.
Watch out on the new sections without barriers. On the Pedemontana near Como and Varese (A36, A59, A60), the A33 Asti–Cherasco and the A21racc south of Brescia, a camera records the license plate. Payment is made online or via app within 15 days. Ask at pickup whether your rental car has a transponder; if it does, payment is automatic.
Traffic rules that surprise German drivers
- Speed: 50 in built-up areas, 90 outside built-up areas, 110 on expressways, 130 km/h on highways. In rain or snow, 90 and 110 apply.
- New drivers who have held their license for less than three years: 90 on expressways, 100 on highways and 0.0 per mille blood alcohol. The Federal Foreign Office also cites the alcohol ban for drivers under 21.
- Otherwise, the limit is 0.5 per mille.
- Outside built-up areas and on highways, low-beam headlights or daytime running lights are mandatory during the day.
- Vehicles driving uphill have the right of way, and on mountain roads, scheduled buses always do.
- Parking lines: black and yellow means absolutely no parking, blue usually means paid parking, yellow is reserved, white is free.
According to ADAC, children under 150 cm and under 36 kg may only ride in a suitable child seat. For children under four, a seat in an Italian rental car also needs an approved warning system to prevent them from being forgotten in the car. Ask about it when you rent the seat along with the car. More in the child car seat guide.
What fines cost
None of these mistakes is cheap. The ADAC table of fines lists (as of May 2026):
- 20 km/h over the limit (ADAC): from 175 euros
- Running a red light (ADAC): from 170 euros
- Phone at the wheel (ADAC): from 250 euros
- Drunk driving (ADAC): from 545 euros
- Illegal parking (ADAC): from 45 euros
At night between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m., the amounts are a third higher. If you pay within five days of delivery, you get a 30 percent discount for most offenses. After 60 days, the amount doubles. The notice must be mailed within 360 days of the offense, and the postmark is what counts. So a letter from Italy can arrive almost a year after your vacation.
Good news for renters: according to the European Consumer Centre, the Italian competition authority banned the fee that rental companies otherwise charge for passing on the driver’s details in June 2022.
Parking, refueling, return
According to the Federal Foreign Office, car break-ins are common, especially near beaches such as in Ostia, Fiumicino and Fregene near Rome, and in unattended parking spaces. Leave nothing in the car and the glove compartment open so that a break-in isn’t worth it.
Return the car with a full tank. The rental stations‘ refueling service charges a fixed price per liter that can be higher than the local rate, plus a refueling fee. Both are charged to your credit card. If you want to take the car to an island, say so before renting. Ferries can incur extra fees, and some classes are excluded. The guide Renting a car in Sardinia (in German) presents that island itself.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an international driver’s license?
No, the EU driver’s license is sufficient.
Is a dashcam allowed?
According to ADAC, yes, as long as it is easy to remove and continuously overwrites its recordings. The dashcam guide gives an overview.
What should I do after an accident?
Report accidents with injuries to the police immediately; the emergency number is 112. For damage to property only, ADAC recommends the European Accident Statement. Everything else is covered in the guide Accidents with a rental car (in German).
Do I need winter tires in winter?
There is no uniform rule. In South Tyrol and on the Brenner highway, winter equipment is required from November 15 to April 15, and in the Aosta Valley from October 15. Ask the rental company if you are driving into the mountains.
General information on booking is in the guide Booking a rental car.
Frequently asked questions
What is a ZTL in Italy?
ZTL stands for Zona a traffico limitato, a restricted-traffic zone in many city centers. The driving bans apply at the times shown on the sign. According to ADAC, anyone who drives in without authorization risks a heavy fine. Park at the edge of the historic center and walk the last stretch, even if the navigation system keeps guiding you on.
How do I pay the highway toll with a rental car in Italy?
You take a ticket when you get on and pay when you get off, even if the barrier is open. According to ADAC, without a ticket you face a penalty fee plus the maximum amount. At the exit, white stands for cash, blue for card and yellow for Telepass. On sections without barriers, you pay online within 15 days.
How long after a vacation can an Italian traffic ticket arrive?
The notice must be mailed within 360 days of the offense, and the postmark is what counts. So a letter can arrive almost a year later. If you pay within five days of delivery, you get a 30 percent discount for most offenses; after 60 days, the amount doubles.
Can the rental company charge a fee for passing on my details?
Not in Italy anymore. According to the European Consumer Centre, the Italian competition authority banned this fee in June 2022. You still pay the fine itself, and at night between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m., the amounts are a third higher.
Which traffic rules surprise German drivers in Italy?
Outside built-up areas and on highways, low-beam headlights or daytime running lights are mandatory during the day. Vehicles driving uphill have the right of way, and on mountain roads, scheduled buses always do. In rain or snow, 90 and 110 apply instead of 110 and 130. New drivers who have held their license for less than three years must drive with 0.0 blood alcohol.
What does a child seat in an Italian rental car need to have?
According to ADAC, children under 150 cm and under 36 kg may only ride in a suitable child seat. For children under four, a seat in an Italian rental car also needs an approved warning system to prevent them from being forgotten in the car. Ask about it when you rent the seat along with the car.
Sources
- ADAC Autovermietung: Rental car Italy
- ADAC: Rental cars at home and abroad
- ADAC: Traffic rules in Italy
- ADAC: Tolls in Italy
- ADAC: Fines in Italy
- German Federal Foreign Office: Italy, travel and safety advice
- European Consumer Centre (Europäisches Verbraucherzentrum): Rental cars
Where to buy
- Mietwagen mit Vollkasko ohne SelbstbeteiligungView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Mietwagen als KleinwagenView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Mietwagen mit FährerlaubnisView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






