Contents8 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Rent or buy? With your internet contract, you can rent a router from the provider, month after month. But you do not have to. Since August 1, 2016, router freedom has applied in Germany: you may connect any suitable device you have bought yourself. Whether that pays off depends less on money than on the question of who looks after the device.
Your right to your own router
The legal basis is now Section 73 of the German Telecommunications Act (TKG). The connection ends at a passive network termination point, that is, at the wall socket in your home, not at the router. Providers may supply you with a device but may not require you to use it. They may not reject a device that meets the technical requirements.
And the access credentials? By law, the provider must hand them over in text form, unprompted and free of charge when the contract is concluded. This also applies to fiber. There, routers with a built-in fiber modem connect directly to the wall socket. Existing customers have the same right: in 2016, the Essen Regional Court ruled that a provider must also give the credentials to customers with older contracts (case no. 45 O 56/16, final and binding).
What speaks for your own router
You choose the device to suit your needs, for example with strong Wi-Fi, mesh support or ports for a phone and network storage. When you switch to another provider with the same technology, you take it with you. And the monthly rental disappears.
The Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) does the math on how much that is. Rental devices are often only the basic version. If you want Wi-Fi or a better model, you usually pay 3 to 7 euros more a month, according to the Verbraucherzentrale. An example calculation: over 24 months, that comes to 72 to 168 euros, plus the costs of sending the device back at the end of the contract. That puts you close to the purchase price of a device of your own after two years.
Then there is freedom. No provider dictates which device sits in your hallway.
What speaks against it
The responsibility lies with you. For your own router, the Verbraucherzentrale explicitly assumes technical knowledge, because installation and setup are up to you. You are responsible for security updates yourself, even if automatic updates are switched on. That has consequences: if a security vulnerability leads to damage, such as a high phone bill, you must prove, according to the Verbraucherzentrale, that you promptly implemented the protective measures recommended by the manufacturer.
If the device breaks, your point of contact under the statutory warranty is the retailer, not the internet provider. There is no remote maintenance by the provider; you handle setup and settings yourself. If you would rather not set up technology yourself, the rental device is the more relaxed option.
| Connection | Own router possible | Note |
|---|---|---|
| DSL plan with your own router | yes, access credentials from the provider | make sure it supports VDSL |
| Cable plan with your own router | yes | find out beforehand how your own device is registered |
| Fiber plan with your own router | yes | router with fiber modem or a separate modem |
No router fits everything
A DSL router works only on DSL, a cable router only on a cable connection and a fiber router only on fiber. If you switch from DSL to cable or fiber, you therefore usually cannot keep using your device. Check this before you sign up for a plan with a different technology.
The second mistake: an old device from the drawer. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, older routers often do not meet current standards. Which requirements apply is stated on your provider’s website. With fiber, combined modem-router devices are worth a look; according to the Verbraucherzentrale, they use less power than two separate devices.
How to switch, step by step
- Check the connection type in your contract: DSL, cable or fiber.
- Read the technical requirements on the provider’s website and choose a suitable device.
- Have your access credentials ready. If they are missing, request them in writing and refer to Section 73 TKG.
- Connect and set up the router, and switch on automatic updates.
- Return the rental device as instructed by the provider and keep the shipping receipt.
Frequently asked questions
Can my fiber provider dictate which modem I use?
No. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, fiber providers must also respect free choice of equipment. Make sure the contract states this.
What does it cost to get the access credentials?
Nothing. The law requires them to be handed over free of charge.
Will the provider still help with faults?
Not for your own device. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, there is no remote maintenance in that case; router settings remain your business.
Is one router enough for the whole home?
That depends on the floor plan and construction. Where the Wi-Fi does not reach every room, additional mesh points help; more on this in the guide Buying mesh Wi-Fi.
Our advice
Before buying, check whether the device matches your connection and whether you can set it up yourself. Weigh rental against purchase price over the term. And use the moment to review your plan as well, as the Verbraucherzentrale recommends: especially with older contracts, you often get more performance for the same price. We present suitable devices in the guide to DSL and fiber routers; switching plans is explained in the guide Switching internet providers, and the path to your own line in the guide Fiber connection.
If the problem is not the router but the line, read the guide The right to fast internet (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Can I use my own router on my internet connection?
Yes. Router freedom has applied since August 1, 2016, and is now regulated in Section 73 of the German Telecommunications Act (TKG). The connection ends at the wall socket in your home. Providers may supply a device but may not require you to use it, and they may not reject a suitable device.
Does the provider have to give me the access credentials?
Yes. By law, in text form, unprompted and free of charge when the contract is concluded, including for fiber. Existing customers have the same right, as the Essen Regional Court ruled in 2016. If the credentials are missing, request them in writing and refer to Section 73 TKG.
Is your own router worth it compared with a rental device?
Rental devices are often only the basic version. For Wi-Fi or a better model, providers usually charge a monthly surcharge, according to the Verbraucherzentrale. Over 24 months, that brings you close to the purchase price of a device of your own, plus the costs of sending it back at the end of the contract.
What speaks against your own router?
Installation, setup and security updates are up to you; there is no remote maintenance by the provider. If a security vulnerability leads to damage, you must prove, according to the Verbraucherzentrale, that you promptly implemented the recommended protective measures. If the device fails, the retailer is responsible.
Can I also use my DSL router with cable or fiber?
Usually not. A DSL router works only on DSL, a cable router only on a cable connection and a fiber router only on fiber. Check this before you sign up for a plan with a different technology. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, older routers also often do not meet current standards.
Can the fiber provider dictate which modem I use?
No. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, fiber providers must also respect free choice of equipment; make sure the contract states this. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, combined modem-router devices use less power than two separate devices.
Sources
- Verbraucherzentrale: Switching your internet router
- Verbraucherzentrale: Router freedom also applies to existing customers
- Verbraucherzentrale: Fiber, free choice of equipment
- Section 73 of the German Telecommunications Act
Where to buy
- DSL-Tarif mit eigenem RouterView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Kabel-Tarif mit eigenem RouterView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Glasfaser-Tarif mit eigenem RouterView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
