Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Bank statements, pay slips, doctors‘ letters: for papers like these, a strip-cut shredder is the wrong choice. If you are destroying personal data, go for a cross-cut (particle-cut) shredder with security level P-4. In a typical household, around ten sheets per pass and a bin of a good 20 liters are enough for that. More money? That only belongs in a shredder once you regularly need to get rid of entire binders at once.
What the standard really says: P-1 to P-7
The security levels come from the German standard DIN 66399, known internationally as ISO/IEC 21964. For paper, they carry a „P.“ According to the overview from the manufacturer HSM, P-1 and P-2 still allow strips no wider than 12 and 6 millimeters, respectively. From P-3 onward, the area of each particle counts: at most 320 mm² for P-3, 160 mm² for P-4, 30 mm² for P-5, 10 mm² for P-6 and 5 mm² for P-7.
Do the math. A particle of 4 x 28 millimeters measures 112 mm² and therefore falls safely within P-4. Mathematically, an A4 sheet breaks down into a good 550 pieces this way. A 6-millimeter strip cut turns it into 35 long strips that can be pieced back together with a little patience.
HSM assigns documents such as pay slips, personnel files, employment contracts and individuals‘ tax documents to level 4 and recommends P-4 and higher for personal data. That is a manufacturer’s recommendation, not a legal requirement. The overview therefore proceeds in steps: first determine the protection class of the documents, then derive the level. In the same overview, medical reports and patent documents are listed under level 5.
And the GDPR?
We are not aware of any obligation for private individuals to use a specific level. What is clear, however, is what the Serviceportal Baden-Württemberg (a German state’s public service portal) states in a text approved by the state commissioner for data protection: destroying personal data is processing within the meaning of the GDPR. If you destroy data yourself, you must implement the necessary technical and organizational safeguards. If you hire a service provider, you remain responsible until the destruction is complete. For freelancers and small offices, that means the device’s level should match the protection needs of the documents, and you should be able to justify it.
How much paper, and for how long at a stretch?
The level is settled. Now it is about quantity and stamina.
Manufacturers‘ sheet capacities usually apply to 70 or 80 g/m² paper. Folded letters or thicker paper noticeably reduce that figure. For bin volume, a rule of thumb from HSM helps: 20 liters hold about 250 sheets. Because cross-cut shreds compact less well than strips, the bin fills up faster than you think.
Small machines run for a few minutes and then need a long break. If you clear out your tax binder once a year, you will notice that right away. An auto-feed machine, by contrast, pulls in an entire stack by itself. That costs considerably more. But it saves the actual work.
According to the manufacturers, all the models below handle staples and small paper clips. You should still oil cross-cut shredders regularly; Fellowes and HSM recommend doing so about every time you empty the bin.
Five cross-cut paper shredders
Leitz IQ Home Office P-4
For this model (item 80090000), Leitz specifies a 4 x 28 millimeter cross-cut, ten sheets at 80 g/m² and a 23-liter bin that, according to Leitz, holds around 225 sheets. After six minutes of continuous operation, the machine requires an hour of cooling time. It handles mail and receipts. For the big annual clear-out, it gets tight. Leitz offers a two-year warranty, three years after registration.
HSM shredstar X10
The small HSM machine cuts 4.5 x 30 millimeters, achieving P-4. It takes ten sheets as well as credit and loyalty cards and has a separate cutting unit for CDs and DVDs. The bin holds 20 liters. HSM does not state a continuous run time on the product page; according to the FAQ, the shredstar X series needs a break of about 60 minutes after overheating.
HSM shredstar X6pro
Same housing, finer cut: 2 x 15 millimeters makes 30 mm² and therefore P-5. In return, it only takes six sheets. If you destroy patient records, contracts containing trade secrets or other people’s documents, you get one extra level of reserve here. For normal household mail, that is more effort than necessary.
Fellowes Powershred 79Ci
According to the user manual, the 79Ci cuts 4 x 38 millimeters, which is 152 mm² and just within P-4. It handles 16 sheets at 70 g/m² and runs for a maximum of 20 minutes at a stretch, followed by 30 minutes of cooling time. Fellowes gives 500 sheets a day as a guideline. The bin volume is not in the manual; retailers list 23 liters. The manual dates from 2017. So the model has been on the market for some time.
Rexel Optimum AutoFeed+ 150X
You can load up to 150 sheets (80 g/m²) here. The feeder takes care of the rest. Rexel specifies P-4 with 4 x 28 millimeters, plus a 44-liter pull-out bin and 30 minutes of continuous operation with fan cooling. For single sheets, there is a manual feed slot for eight sheets. According to the manufacturer, the machine and cutting unit have a two-year warranty. A private household simply does not have enough paper for this much machine.
IDEAL builds one size larger still: according to the manufacturer, the 2445 CC office shredder cuts 4 x 40 millimeters at P-4, handles 11 to 13 sheets, has a 35-liter bin and is made in Germany. It could not be found reliably on Amazon.de; it is more of a product for specialist retailers. If you want to digitize your documents first and then destroy them, the document scanner guide shows suitable devices.
From the kitchen table to the law firm: finding the right device
- Private household, mail and bank statements: Leitz IQ Home Office P-4. P-4, a 23-liter bin and an openly stated run time.
- Households that also want to get rid of old CDs and cards: HSM shredstar X10 with its own CD cutting unit.
- Medical practice, law firm, highly confidential documents: HSM shredstar X6pro with P-5, if six sheets per pass are enough. Otherwise, a larger P-5 machine or a certified destruction service is the better choice.
- Small office with several people: Fellowes Powershred 79Ci for its 20-minute run time.
- If you regularly empty entire binders: Rexel Optimum AutoFeed+ 150X. The feeder saves the time you would otherwise spend standing at the machine.
We would no longer buy a strip-cut machine for papers with names, account numbers or health data. The difference in the result is too great. If a new printer is also due, the laser printer guide will help.
Frequently asked questions
Which security level does a shredder need for private documents?
For personal data such as pay slips or tax documents, the manufacturer HSM recommends P-4 and higher. That is a manufacturer's recommendation, not a legal requirement. At P-4, each particle may be no larger than 160 mm². The same overview assigns medical reports and patent documents to level 5.
What is the difference between strip-cut and cross-cut?
P-1 and P-2 still allow strips 12 and 6 millimeters wide, respectively. A 6-millimeter strip cut turns an A4 sheet into 35 long strips that can be pieced back together. A 4 x 28 millimeter particle cut breaks the same sheet down into a good 550 pieces, mathematically speaking.
Does the GDPR prescribe a security level?
We are not aware of any obligation for private individuals to use a specific level. However, destroying personal data counts as processing within the meaning of the GDPR. For freelancers and small offices, that means the device's level should match the protection needs of the documents and be justifiable.
How large should the bin be?
According to a rule of thumb from HSM, 20 liters hold about 250 sheets. Cross-cut shreds compact less well than strips, so the bin fills faster than expected. For a typical household, a bin of a good 20 liters is enough; for offices, the Rexel AutoFeed+ 150X comes with 44 liters.
How long can a paper shredder run continuously?
Small machines run for a few minutes and then need a long break: the Leitz IQ Home Office requires an hour of cooling time after six minutes. According to the manual, the Fellowes Powershred 79Ci runs for 20 minutes, followed by a 30-minute break. The Rexel AutoFeed+ 150X manages 30 minutes with fan cooling.
Do you need to oil a paper shredder?
Yes, cross-cut shredders should be oiled regularly. Fellowes and HSM recommend doing so about every time you empty the bin. According to the manufacturers, all the models presented handle staples and small paper clips, but folded letters or thicker paper noticeably reduce the possible number of sheets.
Sources
- HSM: Security levels under ISO/IEC 21964 (DIN 66399), PDF
- Serviceportal Baden-Württemberg: Data protection when destroying data carriers (approved by the state commissioner for data protection)
- Leitz: IQ Aktenvernichter Home Office P4
- HSM: shredstar X10
- HSM: shredstar X6pro
- HSM: FAQ on the shredstar series
- Fellowes: Powershred 79Ci user manual, PDF
- Rexel: Optimum AutoFeed+ 150X
- IDEAL: 2445 CC P-4
Where to buy
- Leitz IQ Home Office P-4Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- HSM shredstar X10Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- HSM shredstar X6proCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Fellowes Powershred 79CiCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rexel Optimum AutoFeed+ 150XCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.







