Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A 12-volt TV isn’t a power guzzler. The problem in a motorhome lies elsewhere: in the weight on the wall arm, the space above the seating area, and the question of what drains the battery overnight in standby mode. We’re not giving a main recommendation, because we’re not aware of any measurements by independent testers of these devices; all figures here are manufacturer data. According to this data, the Caratec Vision CAV222E-S places the fewest demands on the wall arm: 2.5 kilos, 44 millimeters deep, disconnection from power at the device switch. If you’re only looking for a small second TV for a mains outlet, you’re better off with the guide to the small TV (in German).
How much battery does an evening of TV cost?
Less than many fear. In its energy data sheet, Alphatronics states 15 watts for the SL-24 DW, and Caratec less than 15 watts for its two devices. Let’s calculate with an onboard voltage of 12.5 volts, which is our assumption: 15 watts divided by 12.5 volts gives 1.2 amps. So three hours of evening viewing cost 3.6 amp-hours. Caratec arrives at the same picture by a different route, stating around 2.5 Ah per feature film for a 22-inch device.
A week without shore power thus adds up to a good 25 Ah. With a 95 Ah battery of which you only want to use half (also an assumption), around half of the reserve is spoken for. Sounds like a lot? But the cooler box, lights and heater fan are running alongside. And the 15 watts is a standard value. Loud sound and full brightness are likely to draw more. So better calculate with a reserve, and plan the satellite system separately, because it isn’t included in these values.
Standby mode is underestimated. Alphatronics states under 0.5 watts, Caratec under 1 watt. In the worst case, that’s 12 or 24 watt-hours per day, so almost 1 or almost 2 Ah. If the vehicle sits parked for two weeks, 13 to 27 Ah are lost this way without anyone watching TV. The solution is simple. All four devices have an on/off switch, and Caratec states 0.00 watts for the off state. Use it; the remote alone isn’t enough. The rest of your power budget is covered in the guide to the power station in a motorhome (in German), and how the leisure battery gets recharged on the road is explained in the article on the battery-to-battery charger (in German).
Can’t the old TV run on an inverter?
It can. It just rarely pays off. Let’s assume an inverter that loses 15 percent and draws 6.5 watts at idle. Then 15 watts become roughly 24 watts, and the evening costs almost 6 instead of 3.6 Ah. Add a second device in the storage space and thick cables, as described in the guide to the 12 V to 230 V inverter (in German).
Another point weighs more heavily. A living room TV isn’t built for driving. Caratec lists its devices as approved under the vehicle regulation ECE R10 and the power supply as designed for use in motor vehicles. Alphatronics mentions corrosion protection for the electronics, overvoltage and reverse polarity protection. These are manufacturer claims. We’re not aware of independent long-term data on these devices.
What voltage does the device need to tolerate?
The box always says 12 volts, but the data sheet says more. Caratec states 10 to 30 volts, Alphatronics 10.5 to 30 volts. For everyday use on the leisure battery, both are enough. Half a volt more headroom at the bottom is nice, but no reason to buy. The 30 volts at the top are intended for trucks and 24-volt onboard systems.
The cable rarely causes problems. Caratec includes a 12-volt cable with a combination plug for the onboard socket and cigarette lighter, and Alphatronics also includes a cigarette lighter cable. At 1 to 2 amps, that’s uncritical. No power supply in the box means, by the way, that at home on the 230-volt mains the Caratec only runs with the optional accessory, and as with Alphatronics, the stand is extra there.
Four 12-volt TVs compared
| Model | Size, depth, weight | Voltage, power | Picture, system | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caratec Vision CAV222E-S | 22 inches, 44 mm, 2.5 kg | 10–30 V, under 15 W | Full HD, webOS, 220 cd/m² | Wall arm, tight installation spots |
| Caratec Vision CAV242E-S | 24 inches, 44 mm, 2.8 kg | 10–30 V, under 15 W | Full HD, webOS, 220 cd/m² | More picture on the same arm |
| Alphatronics K-19 W | 19 inches, 54 mm, 2.6 kg | 10.5–30 V, 13 W | HD Ready, webOS Hub, 300 cd/m² | Panel vans, tight niches |
| Alphatronics SL-24 DW | 24 inches, 45 mm, 3.2 kg | 10.5–30 V, 15 W | Full HD, webOS Hub, 300 cd/m², DVD | DVD collection on board |
According to the manufacturers, all four receive DVB-S2 and DVB-T2, so a separate satellite receiver (in German) is unnecessary. Depth and weight are without stand.
Caratec Vision CAV222E-S
A wall arm notices a 2.5-kilo device less in every curve than one with 3.2 kilos. Add 44 millimeters of depth and Full HD. The Magic Remote with voice control and pointer operation is included, which is more pleasant at the folding table than lengthy button pressing. At 220 cd/m², the picture is the dimmest of these four, which hardly matters in the evening. Caratec itself admits that small housings reach their limits acoustically and refers to a soundbar. Another drawback: the power supply for home use is missing, and the manual doesn’t mention a recording function.
Caratec Vision CAV242E-S
The same design two inches larger. Only 300 grams are added, the depth stays the same, and according to the manual, the consumption is in the same class. It only needs more space in width: 542 instead of 497 millimeters. If that fits above the seating area, it’s the choice for anyone who watches from a slightly greater distance in the evening.
Alphatronics K-19 W
At 439 millimeters wide, it fits in niches that are too narrow for 22 inches. 13 watts according to the energy data sheet is the lowest value here, and it also records to an external SSD of up to 1 terabyte and can pause live TV. The data sheet shows compromises in the picture: 1366 × 768 pixels, so HD Ready instead of Full HD. From two meters away in the over-cab area, 19 inches looks small, but in a panel van viewed from the bed it’s perfectly adequate. At 54 millimeters, it’s also the deepest device here.
Alphatronics SL-24 DW
Almost frameless and with a DVD drive. If you watch films from disc on rainy days and don’t expect a network at the pitch, you get both here in 45 millimeters of depth, plus recording to SSD and 300 cd/m². At 542 millimeters wide, though, it needs more space than many a mount offers, and 3.2 kilos is the highest weight in this comparison. Check before buying whether your mount is approved for it.
Satellite, antenna or internet: what do you really need?
A smart TV only helps on the road if data gets through. According to Caratec, a phone as a hotspot works; for longer evenings, a 5G router for the motorhome (in German) is better. Without internet, satellite and DVB-T2 remain. For encrypted private channels in HD, a CI+ module and smartcard are required; that applies to all devices here.
And the picture during the day? Caratec states 220 cd/m², Alphatronics 300 cd/m². That’s enough for the interior, not for the awning in the midday sun. If you want to watch outside, you’re buying the wrong device.
How we would decide
Measure first, then order. Reimo rightly points out that the installation situation determines the screen size. Note the width, height and usable depth at the installation spot including the mount, and look at the VESA size: all four have 100 × 100 mm, which is also explained in the guide to the TV wall mount. Suitable small parts for the pitch can be found in the article on motorhome accessories (in German).
- Wall arm or narrow console: Caratec Vision CAV222E-S.
- Bigger picture with the same weight problem: Caratec Vision CAV242E-S.
- Very little space or recordings matter: Alphatronics K-19 W, if HD Ready is enough.
- DVDs stay on board: Alphatronics SL-24 DW.
If in doubt, choose 22 rather than 24 inches. The eye forgives size; the drive doesn’t forgive weight on the arm. Basics on panel technology and picture are in the general guide Buying a TV (in German).
Frequently asked questions
How much battery does a 12-volt TV use in a motorhome?
Less than many fear. Alphatronics states 15 watts for the SL-24 DW, Caratec less than 15 watts. At an assumed onboard voltage of 12.5 volts, that's 1.2 amps, so three hours of evening viewing cost 3.6 amp-hours. Loud sound and full brightness are likely to draw more, and the satellite system counts separately.
Why should you switch the TV in a motorhome off completely?
Standby mode is underestimated. Alphatronics states under 0.5 watts, Caratec under 1 watt. If the vehicle sits parked for two weeks, 13 to 27 Ah are lost this way without anyone watching TV. All four devices have an on/off switch; the remote alone isn't enough.
Can you run a normal TV on an inverter in a motorhome?
It's possible, but it rarely pays off. With converter losses and idle draw, 15 watts become roughly 24 watts, and the evening costs almost 6 instead of 3.6 Ah. Add a second device and thick cables. Also, a living room TV isn't built for driving, while Caratec lists its devices as approved under ECE R10.
Does a motorhome TV need a separate satellite receiver?
No, according to the manufacturers, all four devices compared receive DVB-S2 and DVB-T2. For encrypted private channels in HD, a CI+ module and smartcard are required. For streaming, the smart TV needs data, for example via a phone as a hotspot or a 5G router for the motorhome.
What should you look for when installing a TV in a motorhome?
Measure first, then order. Note the width, height and usable depth at the installation spot including the mount, and check the VESA size; all four devices have 100 × 100 mm. Also check whether the mount is approved for the weight. If in doubt, choose 22 rather than 24 inches, because the drive doesn't forgive weight on the arm.
Is a 12-volt TV bright enough for outdoors?
No. Caratec states 220 cd/m², Alphatronics 300 cd/m². That's enough for the interior, not for the awning in the midday sun. If you want to watch outside, these are the wrong devices.
Sources
- Caratec: Vision CAV222E-S
- Caratec: Vision CAV242E-S
- Caratec: Operating manual with technical data
- Alphatronics: K line
- Alphatronics: K-19 W data sheet
- Alphatronics: K-19 W energy data sheet
- Alphatronics: SL line
- Alphatronics: SL-24 DW data sheet
- Alphatronics: SL-24 DW energy data sheet
- Reimo: Notes on 12-volt TVs (retailer information, German)
Where to buy
- Caratec Vision CAV222E-SCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Caratec Vision CAV242E-SCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Alphatronics K-19 WCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Alphatronics SL-24 DWCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
