Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
If the gas boiler breaks down in January, a convector will rescue the living room for a few days. As a permanent solution for an entire apartment, it is no good. In between lies the case that usually matters: a guest room, a hobby room, the granny flat without radiators. There, a controlled wall convector can be justifiable if the room is small and rarely used. We do not have test results for individual models, so here we classify by use case and do not name a winner.
What a convector can and cannot do
A heating wire or heating plate warms air, which flows out at the top and draws in cold air at the bottom. No fan is needed for this, so the device usually runs quietly. At the same time, the German automobile club ADAC names the weakness: the circulation stirs up house dust, which is usually not ideal for allergy sufferers in continuous operation. And because there is no storage core, the warmth soon fades after switching off.
Even so, it is not more economical than other electric heaters, but not worse either. They all convert electricity almost completely into heat. For the same amount of heat, they need a similar amount of electricity; differences come from the controls and the room. If you read about especially energy-saving convectors in an offer, keep that in mind. A good controller saves energy because it heats less. There is nothing more to it. By the way, according to the ADAC, an oil-filled radiator costs about the same in continuous operation; it just releases its heat more slowly.
Emergency heat: what ten days consume
Let’s assume the gas boiler fails for ten days, in a room of 20 square meters. The ADAC says that in everyday use, the thermostat often pushes a device down to 50 to 70 percent of full load. Our assumption: 2,000 watts, 60 percent, twelve hours a day. That is 14.4 kilowatt hours a day, 144 over ten days. Annoying. But manageable, because a year of continuous operation in the same room is around twenty times higher.
The device does not need to be expensive for this. It needs to be able to stand and have a thermostat. And the wiring has to cooperate. Two convectors with 2,000 watts each on the same circuit quickly trip the breaker, and in the kitchen the electric kettle comes on top. So connect the devices to separate circuits. The German energy advice organization co2online also advises against running powerful heaters on one outlet together with other appliances.
One more misconception. A convector does not help in a power outage. How to keep the heating supplied in that case is explained in the guide heating during a power outage. A power station can only carry 2,000 watts briefly, as the runtime calculation quickly shows.
The permanent solution: why the math tips over
The ADAC compares an older building of 100 square meters with a heat demand of 15,000 kilowatt hours. It puts gas at 12 cents per kilowatt hour and electricity at 37 cents, so the same heat from direct electric heating costs around three times as much. A heat pump with a seasonal performance factor of 3 needs only 5,000 kilowatt hours of electricity and thus ends up roughly on par with gas. The convector belongs to the expensive electric option, not to the heat pump.
Broken down to a single room, with the same 150 kilowatt hours per square meter: 20 square meters need around 3,000 kilowatt hours a year, at three times the price of gas. If the room is used every day, the purchase price quickly becomes a minor matter. With just a few weekends a year, it looks different. Then only a fraction of that is incurred.
In 2022, the German consumer testing organization Stiftung Warentest calculated what it costs to heat a living room electrically over the winter. Between the cheapest and the most expensive option lay almost a factor of ten. Depending on the purpose, it said, radiators and convectors are usually safer than fan heaters. What is interesting is how differently the manufacturers themselves put it. Stiebel Eltron describes the CNS 200 Trend as supplementary or transitional heating. AEG Haustechnik, a brand from the same company, speaks of full or transitional heating for its convectors. We consider the first wording the more honest one, except in a very well-insulated room or with your own solar power, which the ADAC also names as a sensible exception.
How large can the room be?
The ADAC rule of thumb is 100 to 150 watts per square meter in an unrenovated older building and 50 to 70 watts in a well-insulated building. For 2,000 watts, that means 13 to 20 square meters in an older building. Trotec states 24 square meters for the TCH 18 E, which only fits better-built houses or milder days. In an older building with 2.40-meter ceilings and old windows, you should rather go with the lower figure. If that is not enough, the 2,500-watt class is the more honest choice than a device that runs nonstop when it freezes.
Four convectors for two jobs
| Model | Design | Output | Protection rating | Controls | Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trotec TCH 18 E | Freestanding unit, 2 kg | 750 / 1,250 / 2,000 W | IP20 | Continuously variable thermostat, frost guard setting | Emergency heat, vacant rooms |
| Stiebel Eltron CNS 200 Trend | Wall unit, 7.7 kg | 2,000 W | IP24 | Weekly timer, frost protection, open-window detection | Rarely used room |
| Bosch Heat Convector 4000-20 | Wall unit, feet available as accessory | 2,000 W | IP24 | 12 to 28 °C, 7 °C frost protection, open-window function | Wall or mobile |
| Bosch Heat Convector 4000-25 | Wall unit, feet available as accessory | 2,500 W | IP24 | Same as 4000-20 | Larger room in an older building |
Trotec TCH 18 E
Emergency heat in the narrower sense. Two kilograms, carrying handles, feet included. Three heat settings and a continuously variable thermostat cover the need, and in the frost guard setting the device switches on before a vacant room gets too cold. The cable is only 1.2 meters long, and with IP20 it has no place in the bathroom. There is no built-in timer; Trotec only offers one as an accessory for the outlet. That does not speak for longer operation.
Stiebel Eltron CNS 200 Trend
The convector for the guest room that is needed on three weekends in winter. The housing is flat, 10 centimeters deep including the wall bracket, but 73.8 centimeters wide, so there needs to be room under the window. With a weekly timer and self-learning controls, it calculates the preheating time itself; open-window detection and frost protection are on board. Protection rating IP24, protection class I. For smaller rooms, the same series is available with 1,000 and 1,500 watts, and choosing one of those often makes more sense than turning down 2,000 watts.
Bosch Heat Convector 4000-20
Hangs on the wall and can also stand freely with the feet available as an accessory. A compromise, then, if it is still open whether the device will stay. According to Bosch, it switches off automatically if it tips over while freestanding. There is also a child lock, heating programs and a controller with adaptive adjustment. The range of 12 to 28 degrees plus 7 degrees frost protection is practical for a vacation room. The feet are not included with the device, so factor them in right away.
Bosch Heat Convector 4000-25
The same series with 2,500 watts, which according to the rule of thumb is enough for 17 to 25 square meters in an older building. More output does not mean more consumption for the same heat, but more load on the circuit. That suits a hobby room that needs to warm up quickly. That much output on a permanent basis? Then something is more likely wrong with the heating.
Three questions before you buy
- Will the device run for more than a few weeks a year? Then first estimate the electricity bill and look at the alternatives in the guide infrared heaters and fan heaters.
- Should it only keep the room frost-free? Then the frost guard is enough; a timer adds little.
- Is the room regularly cold anyway? Then it is worth looking at the controls, see controlling electric heating smartly.
What the convector really consumes in your own home is shown more reliably by an energy meter after a few days than by any table. According to the ADAC, hard-wired wall convectors and anything beyond the outlet are a job for an electrician; a device with 2,000 to 3,000 watts on a plug usually does not need a new line.
Frequently asked questions
Is a convector more economical than other electric heaters?
No, but it is not worse either. All electric heaters convert electricity almost completely into heat and need a similar amount of electricity for the same amount of heat. Differences come from the controls and the room. A good controller saves energy because it heats less. That is how you should read offers for especially energy-saving convectors.
How much electricity does a convector use as emergency heat?
In our example with 2,000 watts, 60 percent load and twelve hours a day, that comes to 14.4 kilowatt hours a day and 144 over ten days. Annoying, but manageable. A year of continuous operation in the same room is around twenty times higher.
Is a convector worthwhile as permanent heating?
Rarely. The German automobile club ADAC calculates gas at 12 cents and electricity at 37 cents per kilowatt hour, so direct electric heat costs around three times as much. A heat pump ends up roughly on par with gas. If a room is used every day, the purchase price is a minor matter. Exceptions are very well-insulated rooms or your own solar power.
How many square meters does a 2,000-watt convector cover?
According to the ADAC rule of thumb of 100 to 150 watts per square meter in an unrenovated older building, 13 to 20 square meters. In a well-insulated building, 50 to 70 watts are enough. Trotec states 24 square meters for the TCH 18 E, which only fits better-built houses. If that is not enough, the 2,500-watt class is the more honest choice.
Can you run two convectors on one outlet?
Better not. Two devices with 2,000 watts each on the same circuit quickly trip the breaker, and in the kitchen the electric kettle comes on top. Connect the devices to separate circuits. The German energy advice organization co2online also advises against running powerful heaters on one outlet together with other appliances.
What is the difference between a wall-mounted and a freestanding convector?
A freestanding unit such as the Trotec TCH 18 E weighs 2 kilograms and is quick to set up, but has IP20 and no built-in timer. Wall units such as the Stiebel Eltron CNS 200 Trend offer IP24, a weekly timer and frost protection. The Bosch Heat Convector 4000 hangs on the wall and can also stand freely with feet from the accessories range.
Sources
- ADAC: Electric heating, costs and consumption of the types compared
- Stiftung Warentest: Heating with electricity
- Stiebel Eltron: CNS 200 Trend product data sheet
- AEG Haustechnik: Convectors
- Bosch: Heat Convector 4000
- Trotec: TCH 18 E convector
- co2online: Fan heater guide
Where to buy
- Trotec TCH 18 ECheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Stiebel Eltron CNS 200 TrendCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bosch Heat Convector 4000-20Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bosch Heat Convector 4000-25Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
