Contents16 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
An infrared panel in the home office that runs from morning to midnight because nobody remembers it in the evening. That is everyday life with many electric heaters. For hardwired panels, convectors and towel warmers, we consider the Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung pro (electric heater control set) the cleanest solution: a wall thermostat and a switch actuator for the flush-mounted wall box, which pair at the push of a button without a hub. If the heater simply plugs into an outlet, the basic version with a plug-in adapter is enough.
What actually gets controlled on an electric heater?
Only the power. A thermostat measures, and an actuator switches the heater on and off. There are no valves here; for those, see our smart radiator thermostats and the guide to smart underfloor heating control. Which heater suits which room is covered in our guide to infrared heaters and fan heaters. Night storage heaters (in German) are a topic of their own.
Often overlooked: the heater must restart on its own after a power interruption. If it waits in standby, it cannot be cycled from outside. Set the built-in controller high enough that the external thermostat takes the lead.
May every electric heater be switched externally?
No, and this is the most important paragraph in this guide. The manual for a Heidenfeld glass convector explicitly prohibits switching the device on and off with programming, a timer or another device, because there is a fire risk if the heater has been covered or set up incorrectly. If the app switches it on while a towel is hanging over it, nobody will notice.
So read your heater’s manual first. If it contains such a ban, stick with the control knob. For permanently mounted panels: cover nothing and keep the clearances specified by the manufacturer.
How much load can a switch actuator handle?
According to the data sheet, the HmIP-FSI16-2 flush-mounted actuator from the pro set switches 14 A continuously, or 3,220 watts, and 16 A for 15 minutes. The HmIP-PS-2 switch plug manages 13 A and 2,990 watts. For „electric radiators and other heating systems,“ however, eQ-3 gives a separate rating for both: 8 A at 200,000 switching cycles. That corresponds to about 1,840 watts.
For a 600 or 1,000 watt panel, that leaves plenty of headroom. With a 2,000 watt convector, it gets tight, and that is exactly where a qualified electrician should weigh in, for example on whether a contactor in the distribution board makes more sense.
One more trap: the Homematic IP wall thermostat with switching output (HmIP-BWTH) sounds suitable, but according to the data sheet it only switches 1 A and 230 watts. It is intended for the actuators of an underfloor heating system, not for a heating panel.
Flush-mounted or plug-in adapter?
The connection decides. If the heater has a plug, the plug-in adapter is the easiest route. For the PS-2, eQ-3 specifies that it may only be plugged into permanently installed Schuko (grounded) outlets, not into power strips, not into extension cords and not daisy-chained with other plug-in adapters.
Hardwired panels and towel warmers need the actuator in the wall box. That means working on the 230-volt mains, and the manual for the HmIP-FSI16-2 leaves no leeway: only by a qualified electrician according to the German VDE 0100 standard. Under Section 13 of the German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (Niederspannungsanschlussverordnung, NAV), changes to the installation downstream of the main service fuse may only be made by the grid operator or registered installation companies anyway. What matters during installation is explained in our guide to the flush-mounted actuator (in German).
Do I need a hub and an app?
Not with the two Homematic sets. The HmIP-WTH-3 wall thermostat and the actuator are connected directly via Push-to-Pair, and according to ELV (German electronics retailer), no internet connection is required. You set up weekly profiles with up to six heating phases using the thermostat’s control wheel. Later, both can be paired with an Access Point.
It is different with the HmIP-FSM16 switch and measurement actuator: it needs an Access Point or a hub. And Shelly relies on Wi-Fi, Zigbee or Matter. There, no wall thermostat comes in the package, and the temperature has to come from a separate sensor.
What does a window contact do?
Otherwise, a panel keeps heating against the cold air while you air out the room. In its Push-to-Pair overview for „electric heating,“ eQ-3 lists the HmIP-SWDM-2 and HmIP-SWDO-PL-2 contacts as compatible, and the wall thermostat has its own window-open symbol on the display. A group there comprises a maximum of five devices. More on the different designs is in our guide to door and window contacts (in German).
And what does it save in the end?
You can work it out. A 1,000 watt panel uses 1 kWh per hour at full load. If it heats three hours less on each of five weekdays, that is 15 kWh per week. Multiply that by the energy rate on your electricity bill (in German). An actuator with a metering function or an energy meter measures it precisely.
Six building blocks for a smart electric heater
| Model | Switches (according to the manufacturer) | Control | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung pro | 14 A continuous (3,220 W), heaters 8 A | Wall thermostat + flush-mounted actuator, no hub | hardwired panels and towel warmers |
| Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung basic | 13 A (2,990 W), heaters 8 A | Wall thermostat + plug-in adapter, no hub | heaters with a plug, rental apartments |
| Homematic IP Schalt-Mess-Aktor 16 A Unterputz, 3er-Set | 12 A continuous (2,760 W), heaters 8 A | Access Point or CCU3, with consumption metering | several rooms in a Homematic system |
| Homematic IP Fenster- und Türkontakt mit Magnet HmIP-SWDM-2 | does not switch, reports | Push-to-Pair or hub | rooms that are aired out often |
| Shelly 1PM Gen4 | 16 A, with power metering | Wi-Fi, Zigbee, Matter | households with their own smart home hub |
| Shelly H&T Gen3 | does not switch, measures temperature and humidity | Wi-Fi, webhooks | sensor for a Shelly solution |
Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung pro
The set combines the HmIP-WTH-3 wall thermostat with display and humidity sensor with the HmIP-FSI16-2 flush-mounted actuator. According to eQ-3, the actuator fits in switch boxes according to the German standard DIN 49073-1 or in surface-mounted boxes and requires a neutral wire. The thermostat runs on two AAA batteries, and ELV states a battery life of about two years. Drawbacks: nothing works without an electrician, there is no consumption metering, and large convectors run up against the 8 A heater rating.
Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung basic
Same thermostat, but with the HmIP-PS-2 switch plug. Plug it in, pair it, set the profile. According to the manual, the plug switches off in case of overload and is only ready again once the cause has been removed and about 30 minutes have passed. The easy way in for renters.
Homematic IP Schalt-Mess-Aktor 16 A Unterputz, 3er-Set
This set of three flush-mounted switch and measurement actuators centers on the HmIP-FSM16, which measures consumption at a resolution of 0.01 watts and switches 2,760 watts continuously, or 3,680 watts briefly for 20 minutes. It requires a neutral wire and an Access Point. Without a hub, it stays silent.
Homematic IP Fenster- und Türkontakt mit Magnet HmIP-SWDM-2
A magnetic window and door contact for frame and sash, glued or screwed on. ELV states a battery life of up to four years. It can be paired with the sets‘ wall thermostat without a hub.
Shelly 1PM Gen4
According to Shelly, the small actuator switches up to 16 A, measures voltage, current and power and explicitly names heaters as an application. It requires a neutral wire and an upstream fuse of no more than 16 A. Shelly does not give a separate heating load rating like eQ-3 does on its product page. Actual regulation only happens with a sensor and an automation, for example in a smart home hub.
Shelly H&T Gen3
The battery-powered sensor measures temperature and humidity and can send readings to other devices via webhook. On battery power, it only measures at intervals.
How we would decide
- Hardwired panel or towel warmer up to about 1,800 watts: the pro set, installed by a qualified electrician.
- Heater with a plug whose manual allows external switching: the basic set.
- Several rooms, keeping an eye on consumption, Homematic already in place: the 16 A switch and measurement actuator, plus window contacts.
- Your own hub with Home Assistant or Matter: Shelly 1PM Gen4 plus a temperature sensor.
Convectors over 2,000 watts? Talk to the electrician first. That is not a question of the app.
How much power a room really needs is calculated in our guide infrared heating: watts per square meter.
When a convector works as an emergency heater and when the math tips the other way is covered in our guide to convector heaters (in German).
Frequently asked questions
May every electric heater be switched via an app?
No. Some manuals explicitly prohibit switching the device on and off with programming, a timer or another device, because there is a fire risk if the heater is covered. If the manual contains such a ban, stick with the control knob. The device must also restart on its own after a power interruption.
How much load can a switch actuator handle for heaters?
For radiators and other heating devices, eQ-3 gives a separate rating of 8 A for both the flush-mounted actuator and the switch plug, which corresponds to about 1,840 watts. For a 600 or 1,000 watt panel, that leaves plenty of headroom; for a 2,000 watt convector, it gets tight.
Flush-mounted actuator or plug-in adapter?
The connection decides. Heaters with a plug are controlled by the plug-in adapter, which belongs only in a permanently installed Schuko (grounded) outlet, not in power strips or extension cords. Hardwired devices need the actuator in the wall box, which only a qualified electrician may install according to the German VDE 0100 standard.
Do I need a hub for electric heater control?
Not with the two Homematic sets: the wall thermostat and actuator are connected directly via Push-to-Pair, and according to ELV no internet is required. You set up weekly profiles with up to six heating phases on the thermostat. The HmIP-FSM16 switch and measurement actuator, on the other hand, needs an Access Point or hub.
Why is the HmIP-BWTH wall thermostat not suitable?
According to the data sheet, it only switches 1 A and 230 watts. It is intended for the actuators of an underfloor heating system, not for a heating panel. The sets with a flush-mounted actuator or switch plug are made for electric heaters.
What does a window contact do for an electric heater?
Without one, a panel keeps heating against the cold air while you air out the room. For electric heating, eQ-3 lists the HmIP-SWDM-2 and HmIP-SWDO-PL-2 contacts as compatible; they can be paired with the wall thermostat without a hub. A group comprises a maximum of five devices.
Sources
- ELV: Set Elektroheizungssteuerung pro
- ELV: Set Elektroheizungssteuerung basic
- eQ-3: HmIP-FSI16-2 data sheet
- eQ-3: HmIP-FSI16-2 manual
- eQ-3: HmIP-PS-2 switch plug manual
- eQ-3: HmIP-WTH-3 wall thermostat manual
- eQ-3: Compatibility between Push-to-Pair products
- eQ-3: HmIP-FSM16 data sheet
- eQ-3: HmIP-BWTH data sheet
- ELV: HmIP-SWDM-2 window and door contact
- Shelly: 1PM Gen4
- Shelly: H&T Gen3
- Heidenfeld: HF-GK100C glass convector user manual
- German Low Voltage Connection Ordinance (NAV), Section 13
Where to buy
- Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung proView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Set Elektroheizungssteuerung basicView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Schalt-Mess-Aktor 16 A Unterputz, 3er-SetView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Fenster- und Türkontakt mit Magnet HmIP-SWDM-2View at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Shelly 1PM Gen4Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Shelly H&T Gen3Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Homematic IP Schalt-Mess-Aktor 16 A UnterputzView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
