Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A lease payment of 249 euros sounds like a manageable car. Whether it really is only becomes clear when you do the math over the entire term: down payment, delivery, registration, excess mileage and whatever counts as damage at the return. If you lease privately, you should therefore know two figures, the lease factor and the total cost factor, and take the return report more seriously than the test drive. For people who can only plan one to two years ahead, a car subscription is often the more honest solution. More expensive per month, but no shopping around for insurance.
What you are actually paying for with private leasing
With leasing, you do not buy a car. You pay for the depreciation during the term, the leasing bank’s interest and its margin. The lessor remains the owner; you are the registered keeper and have to arrange insurance yourself. The German automobile club ADAC points out that leases generally require comprehensive coverage. What that means for an electric car is covered in our guide to car insurance for electric cars.
There are two basic forms on the market. With mileage leasing, you agree on an annual mileage; at the end, only what you drove above or below it is settled, along with the car’s condition. With residual value leasing, the lessor sets at the start what the car should still be worth at the end. If it fetches less, you pay the difference. The automobile club ACE therefore calls residual value leasing a kind of bet that the customer often loses at the return, because an appraisal sets the amount at the end. For private customers, mileage leasing is the predictable choice. According to its own information, allane, a German leasing provider, offers mileage leasing exclusively.
A third variant shows up in many offers: leasing with a purchase option, often called Vario leasing. You pay installments, and at the end you either buy the car at a price fixed in advance or return it against a final payment. If you return it, you must have treated the car just as carefully as a leased car. Many people do not realize this, according to the ACE guide.
Lease factor and total cost factor: two figures, one worked example
The lease factor puts the monthly payment in relation to the gross list price: payment divided by list price, times 100. A factor of 1 means you pay one percent of the list price each month. If it is below that, according to the ADAC, this can indicate an offer that is good value by market standards. There is no fixed threshold. Discounts are not deducted from the list price.
The weakness of the plain lease factor: it ignores everything that is not in the payment. That is why we also calculate the total cost factor. To do so, spread the down payment, delivery and registration over the months of the term and add them to the payment. The ADAC lease calculator works the same way and explicitly asks for these one-time costs.
Worked example (all figures chosen freely, not a real offer): a compact car has a list price of 30,000 euros. The offer is 249 euros a month, 36 months, 10,000 kilometers per year, 2,000 euros down payment. Delivery and registration cost 1,100 euros together.
- Lease factor: 249 ÷ 30,000 × 100 = 0.83. That looks decent.
- One-time costs per month: (2,000 + 1,100) ÷ 36 = 86.11 euros.
- Total cost factor: (249 + 86.11) ÷ 30,000 × 100 = 1.12.
- Total over three years: 36 × 249 + 2,000 + 1,100 = 12,064 euros, so around 335 euros a month.
A good third more than advertised.
So 249 euros turn into 335 euros. Insurance, electricity or fuel, tires and maintenance come on top. Always compare offers by the total cost factor, and only with the same term and the same mileage.
Down payment, delivery, registration: the costs before the first kilometer
A down payment lowers the monthly payment but does not make the offer any cheaper. You just pay the money earlier. For theft or a total loss, the ACE recommends GAP insurance. It covers the gap between the replacement value that comprehensive insurance pays and what the lessor still demands.
According to the ADAC, delivery costs average between 500 and 1,000 euros, and more for some brands. At allane, they are not included in any of the payments shown; an example from the provider’s site: for a SEAT Ibiza on a car subscription, a one-time delivery fee of 1,213.10 euros is due. On a small car, an amount like that noticeably shifts the total cost factor.
Excess and unused kilometers
Estimate your annual mileage honestly. If you set it too low, you pay for every additional kilometer at the contract’s excess mileage rate at the end. If you set it too high, you pay a higher monthly payment for three years; unused kilometers are refunded only partly or not at all. According to the ADAC, the payment for an Opel Frontera rises by about 40 euros a month if you go from 10,000 to 20,000 kilometers a year.
Check whether the contract specifies an allowance or a tolerance threshold. This is not a play on words.
allane works with a tolerance threshold of 2,500 kilometers: if you drive 2,400 kilometers too many, you pay nothing. If you drive 2,700 kilometers too many, you pay for all 2,700 at the agreed rate, not just the 200 above the threshold. At 13 cents per kilometer, which is what allane quotes for the Ibiza subscription, for example, that would be 351 euros.
The return: where leasing can get expensive
At the end comes the return report, usually prepared by an appraiser. What counts as normal wear and tear and what counts as damage is set by the lessor in its assessment criteria. At allane, they are public: accepted are, for example, up to three dents per panel of up to 20 millimeters that need no repainting, scratches on door edges and bumpers under 20 millimeters, and small stone chips of up to 2 millimeters outside the field of vision. Paint damage from bird droppings or tree sap, pet hair and burn holes are charged.
Then there are costs that have nothing to do with the condition. According to its return page, allane charges 172.55 euros for deregistration and the condition report. Drop-off is possible at no extra charge in Berlin-Ludwigsfelde, at the Autohaus24 locations in Eching, Wuppertal and Egelsbach for 249 euros, and at a DEKRA station for 479 euros; pickup at a location of your choice costs 599 euros.
Three things really help. Photograph the car all the way around in daylight when you take it over and shortly before the return. Have small damage repaired during the term, as long as your insurance or a smart repair shop does it more cheaply than the after-the-fact charge. And do not sign a report with items you have not seen yourself.
Car subscription or leasing?
At its core, a car subscription is a short lease with the running costs built in. Insurance, vehicle tax, maintenance and tires are usually included in the monthly price, and with some providers, terms start at six months or less. The ACE points to the fine print: age limits and trips outside the EU are restricted with some providers.
For comparison, a real example from allane, as of November 19, 2026: SEAT Ibiza 1.0 TSI FR on a subscription with purchase option, 30 months, 10,000 kilometers a year, 318 euros a month. On top of that come 1,213.10 euros for delivery and, at the return, a final payment of 780.30 euros. Over 30 months, that comes to 11,533.40 euros, or around 384 euros a month, with insurance and tax already included. You handle the registration yourself there.
Our assessment: if you drive a car for three years or longer, leasing plus your own insurance usually works out cheaper, especially with a good no-claims class. The subscription suits transition periods. A probation period at a new job, a move, a year abroad on the horizon.
Leasing an electric car: subsidy only with 36 months
Since 2026, the German federal government has been subsidizing electric cars again, explicitly including leased ones. According to the consumer advice center Verbraucherzentrale, there are 3,000 to 5,000 euros depending on taxable household income, plus up to 500 euros per child, for a maximum of 6,000 euros in total; the income limit is 80,000 euros, or up to 90,000 euros with children. The registered keeper applies personally, no later than twelve months after registration, via the portal of the Förderzentrale Deutschland.
The decisive sentence is in the FAQ of BAFA, the German federal office responsible: the vehicle must remain registered to the applicant continuously for at least 36 months. Many lease offers run for 24 or 30 months. If you want the bonus, you therefore need a term of at least three years or have to take over the car afterward. Ask about this before you sign. For charging at home, our wallbox guide helps, and for the right tariff, the article on electricity for heat pump and wallbox.
Example models at allane by price class
The following payments come from allane.de, as of November 19, 2026. According to the offer pages, they apply to 30 months, 10,000 kilometers per year and 0 euros down payment, mostly in the version with a purchase option; delivery always comes on top, and leasing without a purchase option is available on request. Payments change with promotions, stock and creditworthiness. Our thresholds: entry-level class up to 300 euros a month, mid-range class 300 to 600 euros, premium class from 600 euros.
| Model | Class | Payment from (allane, 11/2026) | Drive according to the offer | Best for | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Citroën ë-C3 | Entry-level class | €222 | Electric, 113 hp | City and commuting, if you can be patient with delivery | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| Škoda Fabia | Entry-level class | €191 | Gasoline, 80 hp | few trips, no way to charge | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| Renault 5 E-TECH | Mid-range class | €432 | Electric, 122 hp, 317 km WLTP | everyday driving with a wallbox or charging at work | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| Renault 4 E-TECH | Mid-range class | €529 (pre-registered from €504) | Electric, 150 hp | small family, more trunk space | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| Škoda Octavia Combi | Mid-range class | €416 | Diesel, 150 hp, DSG | high-mileage drivers without a charging spot | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| BMW i4 | Premium class | €1,010 | Electric, 401 hp, all-wheel drive | long-distance electric driving, high expectations | View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane |
| BMW 3 Series Touring | Premium class | €636 | Gasoline, 156 hp (318i) | station wagon with premium features | |
| SEAT Ibiza car subscription with purchase option | Car subscription | €318 (30 months) | Gasoline, 95 hp | transition period, insurance included |
Which class suits which everyday life
Entry-level class (up to 300 euros): small cars for the city and short commutes. You get driver assistance systems and air conditioning, but little space and, with an electric car, a smaller battery. Our pick in the entry-level class: Citroën ë-C3, because the payment of 222 euros leaves room for the delivery costs; allane states a delivery time of six months or more. If you cannot charge, take the Škoda Fabia with a gasoline engine.
Mid-range class (300 to 600 euros): this is where most family and commuter cars sit. Our pick in the mid-range class: Renault 5 E-TECH, a compact electric small car with a standard range of 317 kilometers according to the offer and availability in four to eight weeks. The Renault 4 E-TECH offers more space. If you drive a lot on the highway and have no charging spot, the Octavia Combi diesel is the more realistic choice.
Premium class (from 600 euros): more power, comfort and brand, but also higher insurance premiums and more expensive damage at the return. Our pick in the premium class: BMW i4 xDrive40 for anyone who drives long distances electrically. The 3 Series Touring is the alternative with a combustion engine and a large trunk. With payments over 1,000 euros, you should calculate the total cost factor especially carefully.
Who else leases and rents
allane is the former Sixt Leasing: Hyundai Capital Bank Europe took a majority stake in 2020, Sixt Leasing SE became Allane SE in 2021, and the private customer platform Sixt Neuwagen is now also called allane. In addition, the carmakers‘ own banks offer leasing, usually through the dealer and only for their own brand. Brand-independent marketplaces such as LeasingMarkt.de and Vehiculum bundle offers from many dealers. For car subscriptions, FINN is one of the well-known providers; according to the provider, insurance, tax, maintenance and registration are included in the monthly price there, and terms start at six months. The advice stays the same: same term, same mileage, compare total costs.
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate the lease factor?
Monthly payment divided by the gross list price, times 100. A factor of 1 means you pay one percent of the list price each month. For the total cost factor, spread the down payment, delivery and registration over the months and add them to the payment.
Which is better, mileage leasing or residual value leasing?
For private customers, usually mileage leasing. Only excess or unused kilometers and damage are settled at the end. With residual value leasing, you carry the risk that the car is worth less at the end than agreed.
What does it cost to return a leased car?
That is set out in the contract. At allane, according to its return page, 172.55 euros are charged for deregistration and the condition report, plus 0 to 599 euros for the drop-off depending on location, as of 11/2026. Damage beyond normal wear and tear comes on top.
Is the EV subsidy also available for leasing?
Yes, for electric cars newly registered from 2026. According to BAFA, however, the car must remain registered to the applicant continuously for at least 36 months. A lease of 24 or 30 months is not enough on its own.
Is a car subscription more expensive than leasing?
Per month, usually yes, but insurance, vehicle tax and maintenance are often already included. If you plan for three years or longer and have a good no-claims class, leasing with your own insurance usually works out cheaper.
Sources
- ADAC: Calculating the lease factor (in German)
- ADAC: Car leasing cost check (in German)
- ADAC: Delivery costs for leasing (in German)
- ADAC: Ten tips for first-time lessees (in German)
- ACE: Buy, lease or subscribe (in German)
- Verbraucherzentrale: EV bonus 2026 (in German)
- BAFA: FAQ on the EV subsidy (in German)
- allane: Lease return and assessment criteria (in German)
- allane: Lease factor (in German)
- allane: SEAT Ibiza car subscription with purchase option (in German)
- allane: Sixt Neuwagen is now allane (in German)
Where to buy
- Renault 5 E-TECHView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- Citroën ë-C3View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- BMW i4View at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- Škoda FabiaView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- Renault 4 E-TECHView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- Škoda Octavia CombiView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- BMW 3 Series TouringView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
- SEAT Ibiza car subscription with purchase optionView at allaneAvailable in Germany: allane
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.








